R-II officials oppose Amendment 3

ELIZABETH GOLDEN/DAILY FORUM
Superintendent Larry Linthacum gestures during a discussion among members of the Maryville R-II Board of Education on Tuesday about Amendment 3, a proposed state constitutional amendment that would tie student tests scores to teacher evaluations and tenure. Voters will decide whether to adopt the measure in next month’s general election.
The Maryville R-II Board of Education this week unanimously passed a resolution in opposition to Amendment 3, a Missouri ballot measure that would tie teacher evaluations and tenure to student test scores.
Appearing on the Nov. 4 general election ballot, the amendment, if passed, would implement student-performance-based teacher evaluations that districts would use to determine if public school faculty members should be dismissed, retained, demoted or promoted.
In addition, the amendment would require teachers to enter into contracts of three years or less and prohibit teachers from organizing or collectively bargaining regarding the design and implementation of faculty evaluation systems.
This would, in effect, do away with the current teacher tenure law
If passed, say state officials, the measure will have no fiscal impact on taxpayers.
“There are some who think the teacher tenure law supports bad teachers,” said R-II Superintendent Larry Linthacum. “I feel confident as a district that if we don’t feel good for our own children, we will address that.”
Additionally, Linthacum said staff would receive compensation based on student achievement if the amendment is adopted.
“That concept sounds good,” he said, “but then you have your art teachers and your physical education teachers that would be tied to student achievement even if they don’t teach them.”
Linthacum gave the example of a struggling third-grade student who is placed in a classroom based on his or her connection with the teacher.
“It changes the mindset of a teacher, so they might feel they are competing with each other,” he said. “If they feel their pocketbook is tied to how well kids do on the tests, it could cause a dissension. The concept as a whole makes sense in some parts, but overall as a district, we are in opposition to the amendment.”
The amendment has support from wealthy investor Rex Sinquefield, who is financing Grow Missouri, the group behind the initiative.
“You would hope that the motive for the amendment would be for the right reasons,” Linthacum said. “I’m not sure they are for the right reasons of what’s best for kids. The organization might have their own agenda that we feel is not in line with what we feel here in Maryville.”
Linthacum said Sinquefield believes the Missouri education system is broken, financially and otherwise.
“Are there things we could do better and improve? Absolutely.” Linthacum said. “We recognize that, but I don’t feel our education system is broken. There are many elements of our education system that need to be completely overhauled. There are things we could do better, but we do not feel like the system is broken. Their agenda feels it is and wants to completely turn it over.”
In addition to R-II, Amendment 3 is being opposed by teacher unions and public school organizations, which have raised more than $600,000 to fight it.
Due to the pushback, Linthacum said, those behind the amendment have begun taking a back-seat role.
“We feel that is a chess piece,” Linthacum said. “There was so much pushback from it, they felt maybe less would be more. If they took a back seat, the amendment is still not going to die.
“Those at the (Missouri Association of School Administrators) feel it will be on the ballot this time to get the word out. There was so much pushback, (the amendment’s supporters) decided to just back off and it won’t go away.”
The resolution passed by R-II calls the amendment “poorly drafted and deeply flawed,” and argues that there will be unintentional negative consequences for teachers.
The resolution states Amendment 3 will prevent school boards from hiring, compensating or dismissing teachers in accordance with local district policies.
Additionally, the School Board fears, the amendment will force taxpayers to pay for more standardized tests and require districts to use teacher evaluations for other purposes than improved faculty performance.
“The amendment takes away from the improvement of teacher performance, requires additional standardized tests, takes away from local control,” Linthacum said. “Many schools have already adopted this resolution, and it would be used to encourage other schools not to (support the amendment).”
