Skip to content

Even in today’s world, two wrongs do not make a right

Matt Pearl

When I was in my teens, my folks bought a home in Union Star, and soon after our purchasing the place, my parents decided a little bit of light remodeling was in order.

I remember helping Dad cut paneling for the walls in the den, and hanging rails and installing a suspended ceiling. There was a summer where I spackled walls, took a sledge to an old bathtub, knocked out drywall, ripped up carpet––and I even helped put some of it back together again.

I learned a lot from the experience, but chiefly I learned the following: I hate painting.

Even the easy painting is no fun for me, though I have endured the practice many times since my early 1990s work on the folks’ house. Edging up to woodwork and floors is the worst; but painting big expanses of wall with a roller––now that was the job I would choose if I had to pick one painting task.

It was easy: load up the roller, make a ‘W’ shape, fill it in––piece of cake. Broad strokes cover walls quickly, as I soon learned.

But in the symbolic use of the phrase, I have found great harm in the practice of ‘painting with too broad of a stroke.’ That’s the rhetoric by which folks like me, moderate Midwestern conservatives, get lumped in with what is beginning to be called the alt-right.

Harming people who disagree with you is wrong. I’d just like to put that categorical observation on the table. There is no qualifying remark to follow. You can’t kill people when they don’t like you, or you don’t like them.

In fact, the only time when it is excusable to kill is when one’s life is threatened. I could try to sound smarter than I am and pronounce for you specifically how threatened a person should feel before responding with violence, but in my experience different folks seem to have different levels of patience and thresholds of fear.

We are at a moment in history when for holding certain conservative stances on issues, folks like myself are in danger of being sorted in a pile with white supremacists and Ku Klux Klansmen. I hope our fellow Americans do not view us in such a light, and I hope that other right-leaners don’t take the bait and become embittered by such a charge.

The line I draw is a simple one in instances like Charlottesville a few days ago. If you are vocalizing your distaste for someone’s actions, you are protesting. If you are vocalizing your designs to remove people from their homes or threatening their safety, you are inciting violence. What do you do when both sides see their members as the peaceful protesters and the others as the violent thugs?

You remember that you live in America in 2017, and that political division seems to be the only thing we can do with much consistency.

What I would remind folks to do is to remember the difference between the practice of protesting what you perceive to be prejudice and bigotry and that of advocating that there are entire groups of people who do not deserve American rights.

If the first group is wrong, and the bigotry they are alleging is not really there, then they have spoken in error and hurt their own cause. If the second group is wrong, they have still threatened the lives and freedom of entire groups of people. That is a profound difference.

So to those of you who believe both groups are wrong, I say that I can understand your perspective. What we all need to see is that hateful speech (though vile) could arguably be protected constitutionally––but advocating ethnic or racial ‘cleansing’ is not our American way.

Matt Pearl owns and operates newspapers in King City, Albany, and Grant City.

Leave a Comment