Skip to content

J.C. Penney set to close doors Monday

JON DYKSTRA/DAILY FORUM
The Maryville J.C. Penney store will officially close its doors Monday night after learning in March it would be one of 138 stores nationwide that were being shuttered. Maryville’s J.C. Penney dates back to 1920.

For nearly 100 years, J.C. Penney Co. has had a retail store located in Maryville, first downtown and then, beginning in 1981, at the Maryville Mall Shopping Center on South Main.

But in March the company announced it would close 138 stores, and the Maryville location was the only one in Missouri to make the list.

The original closing date was set for June 18, but was pushed back to July 31.

This marks the final weekend for the business, which will shutter its doors for good when it closes Monday at 8 p.m.

“I hate to see it close, but I hate to see Maryville lose another store. That is my main concern,” said Jim Boswell, who managed the Maryville J.C. Penney location from 2005 to 2010. “This is the only one in Missouri closing. It is a bad deal.”

Boswell was transferred to Maryville from a store in Lawrence, Kansas. He noted the Maryville store was “profitable” during his time but that national sales for the big-box retailer had dropped considerably.

According to a March story in Fortune magazine, J.C. Penney — headquartered in Plano, Texas — generated $12 billion dollars in revenue in 2016, but that’s a big drop from 2006 when sales were $19 billion.

The company still has more than 1,000 stores, with the St. Joseph location at East Hills Mall being the closest to Maryville.

Penney’s founder, James Cash Penney, a native of Hamilton, Missouri, opened a Golden Rule Store in Kemmerer, Wyoming, in 1902 and five years later bought out his partners. In 1913, the J.C. Penney brand name originated, and by 1928 Penney had opened 1,000 stores.

The company boomed in the 1950s and 1960s with downtown locations as well as the creation of the J.C. Penney catalog in 1962.

The first Maryville location, now Carson’s Sports Grille, opened at 312 N. Main Street on April 30, 1920. On Sept. 18, 1979, the company announced plans to move into the newly developed Maryville Mall on the south edge of town. J.C. Penney and K-Mart were to anchor the retail center. K-Mart left town in 1985.

According to a Maryville Daily Forum story, economic conditions led to a delay in opening the store, and the groundbreaking ceremony took place Jan. 19, 1981. The business opened later that year on Oct. 14.

O’Riley Brothers Construction Co. of Maryville built the structure for developer Ainbinder Bramalea of Houston, Texas.

“We’re trying to update our facilities and give our customers something nice,” J.C. Penney manager Larry Hoophaw told the Forum during the groundbreaking ceremony.

The move from downtown to Maryville Mall meant a much larger space for the store, which occupied 22,204 square feet as opposed to 4,200 square feet. The number of employees grew from 10 to more than 30.

Now, the City of Maryville and Nodaway County Economic Development will be looking for a new tenant or tenants at the location, as well as one to fill a nearby space vacated by Payless Shoes.

“Certainly, on a national level, we were aware of what was going on at the corporate level with J.C. Penney for many years,” said Maryville City Manager Greg McDanel. “We’ve been talking with the property owner for quite a while. Now that the closing is imminent there is urgency to push hard and find the right tenant. There’s not a lot of big boxes that need 22,000 square feet of space, so it may be two or three different tenants.”

Josh McKim, executive director of NCED, said the goal is to fill the spot as quickly as possible, ideally with another retailer. However, all options are being considered.

As soon as McKim learned J.C. Penney was leaving, the owner and manager of Maryville Mall was contacted to check on the status of finding a new tenant.

“It takes longer than people want it to,” McKim said. “We want it filled. The longer is sets vacant, the harder it gets, and spending habits change in the local market.

“There are good and bad things about the space. It is pretty square, and that creates challenges in dividing. If it was longer in front, it’d be easier to subdivide. There are multiple retailers that are at 20,000 feet or close to it, so the footprint is not uncommon, and we’ve had conversations with some that are right at that.”

PHOTO COURTESY OF JOAN HOOPHAW
Pictured above is the J.C. Penney store prior to its opening in the fall of 1981 at the Maryville Mall Shopping Center. The store will officially close its doors on Monday after a run of 97 years in town.

Leave a Comment