Examining GOP health care

Richard Fulton
Hovering just below the radar of the mass confusion that is politics in Washington D.C. is the work that congress is doing (behind closed doors) on revising and/or replacing Obama’s Affordable Care Act.
President Trump and Republicans claim the act is not working and it must be repealed and replaced. As a matter of fact it is still the law of the land and continues coverage for more people than ever in American history.
There are significant problems with the act, however. Mostly, it needs to be amended to deal with securing insurance company participation with reasonable rates and maintaining pressures on those who refuse to sign up for health insurance.
The House of Representatives has passed a replacement policy called American Health Care Act. It is universally disliked. Only 29 percent of Americans support this Republican abomination.
Indeed, there is not a state in the union where polls show a majority support for the Act, Missouri included with support in the 30 percent range. Our Representative, Sam Graves voted for the act.
Even President Trump calls it “mean” even though he praised it just last month in a Rose Garden press conference. Go figure.
The AARP, among others, hates it. Their analysis says that it includes what they call an “age tax” because it would increase premiums by $13,000 for those 50-64 years old. What’s more, it “would discriminate against people with preexisting conditions…(and) it would cause millions of Americans to lose coverage and put Medicare in worse financial shape.”
In short it would be a disaster for untold millions of Americans.
Republicans have, for eight years, blocked any attempt to fix the things that are not working well in the ACA. The Trump administration has not helped much in finding solutions either. Mostly the president just heaps blame.
He claims that insurance companies are leaving the marketplace because the ACA doesn’t work. But most that have left markets claim the reason is the uncertainty created by Trump’s policies and incoherent tweeting.
They do not know if he will continue the payments to insurers that help cover low-income Americans. They are fearful that he will not enforce the mandate for all Americans to have health insurance, a part of the ACA that makes it financially viable.
Even so Centene, a national health insurance company, recently announced that they are aggressively expanding into more states, including Missouri. There is a market there if treated fairly. So much for Trump’s claim that the ACA is collapsing.
The Senate is working to produce their own version of a repeal and replacement to the ACA. What will be their policies? No one knows since they are doing their work completely behind close doors. Nothing good comes out of the dark in Washington. Even fellow Republican senators don’t know what’s in it.
But leadership expect all Republicans to vote for it anyway; without hearings, without significant debate, without input from American interests. All of which took place when the ACA was considered and passed including nearly 200 Republican amendments.
Some have pointed out that Medicare has worked pretty well for those over 50. This might be a good model for an inclusive health care system. Everyone contributes and everyone is covered.
Did I mention that our representative in the House, Sam Graves, voted for the American Health Care Act? He, evidently, can’t recognize a disaster when it is right before his eyes.
Richard Fulton is an emeritus professor of political science.
