Skip to content

Pop culture contrarian

Tom Pinney

I was very disappointed by La La Land.

I can feel your ire right now as you reach for your pen and paper to start sending me hate mail, but let me explain.

I was so hyped to see that movie that it was the hardest choice in the world when my little sister took me to the movies on a much-needed brother-sister date for my birthday in December when we had to choose between seeing Disney’s latest masterpiece Moana or La La Land. I was happy I chose Moana as the end credits rolled, because good grief, what a film.

Auli’i Cravalho and Lin Manuel Miranda were robbed of the Oscar for Best Original Song, especially since the award went to “City of Stars.” I’m getting off topic.

A few weeks ago, on a weekend where I spent most of the time sitting on my futon blowing my nose because I was hit with my third cold of the year, I used a free Redbox coupon on La La Land. After viewing the film, I wanted my money back.

The film had all the pieces for a great film: the beautifully awkward Emma Stone, brooding hunk Ryan Gosling, and impressive single-take dance numbers, but it failed. Hard.

First off, the songs were nothing to write home about. There was nothing challenging about the music, the lyrics were cut and pasted from an off-Broadway coloring book, and the choreography, while beautiful, was distracting more than contributive.

Second, let’s go to the writing. Save for the very end, I was not drawn into the story. It was a story we’ve heard a hundred times: aspiring (heroine) takes a shot at her dreams, gets banged up a bit, then gives up just before her big break makes itself known, so (male lead) goes and convinces her to give it one more chance, and that one more chance pans out.

Yawn. If I wanted to see that musical, I would watch Rock of Ages. The music was better, the acting was better, and Tom Cruise can sing circles around Ryan Gosling.

If past me saw that sentence, he would wonder why people are comparing the singing abilities of Ryan Gosling and Tom Cruise. He would also wonder why I’m willingly watching a Tom Cruise film, but that’s for a different reason.

Third, let’s talk acting. Ryan Gosling turned in a serviceable performance, and if the piano parts were actually him, color me impressed. But Emma Stone was incredibly wrong for her role.

She did okay with it, but it’s not her story. After an award for Superbad and a great role in Zombieland, she has had roles written for her. This is a role where you need someone who has experienced the constant, crushing feeling of defeat before getting their star turn.

Emma Stone is a great actress who was simply not right for this role. For me, it was like Harrison Ford in Jackie Robinson biopic 42: replace them with anyone else, and the quality of the film has no change.

A week later, when I was surprised with another free Redbox, I decided to use it on a movie called Lion. While I had heard nothing but good about this film, I was caught off guard by just how much I was impressed by it.

Lion follows the true story of Saroo Brierly, an Indian man who was adopted as a boy by an Australian family, as he searches for his true home. It is an absolutely beautiful tale, and star Dev Patel was downright incredible.

Therein lies the rub. My tastes sometimes make me feel like a contrarian for popular culture.

There are so many things that I’m supposed to love in this world that I just don’t.

A couple of examples: I think LeBron James is a great basketball player, but I absolutely dislike him because he’s a prima donna who is cheating on his wife with his own reflection.

If meaningless platitudes didn’t exist, Katy Perry wouldn’t have a career. If Nicki Minaj didn’t hold grudges, neither would she.

If people stopped dating Taylor Swift, her career would end tomorrow. And the only movie with Ryan Gosling in it that I enjoyed was entirely because of reasons not related to Ryan Gosling.

Ryan Reynolds… no, wait, Ryan Reynolds is a national treasure, and America should forever be jealous that he’s Canadian. By the way, Canada, because of Ryan Reynolds, we forgive you for Justin Bieber who, again, I dislike with a passion I can only call religious.

I turn away from the Top 40 style of music, your pop, hip hop, R&B, etc., in favor of heavy metal, alt-rock, melodic rock, and The Piano Guys. That includes Christian music; I much prefer the heavy music over your bubblegum CCM.

Maybe it’s the message of non-conformity that was ironically popular when I was in middle school, but I like it. I feel comfortable having my own opinions on things that many people don’t share, but like with anything, I can back up my opinions with reasons.

As we enter into a summer full of blockbuster movies and numerous album releases, remember that every person is different no matter how much some people like to group us together. Generalizations never speak to the individual.

So if you like a movie you’re supposed to hate, if you hate an album you’re supposed to love, it’s perfectly fine. No one can tell you how to feel about something.

You do you. No one else can do it for you.

And if you missed that last bit, don’t worry; it will be on Katy Perry’s next album.

Tom Pinney is a news reporter for the Maryville Daily Forum

Leave a Comment