Health insurance blues

Richard Fulton
After six long years of pledging to repeal the Affordable Care Act (ACA) without trying to make even one adjustment to make the act work better, Republicans in Congress have finally come up with a plan of their own.
Sort of. Many Republicans do not want to associate with the plan presented by the Speaker of the House Paul Ryan so we’ll see if they can get together.
Why? One reason is the report on the plan by the bipartisan Congressional Budget Office estimates that the Republican plan would result in 24 million fewer Americans being covered by health insurance in the next decade; 14 million by 2018.
And most of those newly uninsured would come from the ranks of older Americans and from the lower and middle income earners. In short, from those who would not be able to afford the insurance, even with the subsidies offered by the Republican plan.
The ACA gives subsidies for lower and middle income folks and puts restrictions on insurance companies so they can’t dump those with preexisting conditions. It also lets those up to 26 years old stay on their parent’s plans.
President Trump, after finally beginning to address health care, famously said “who knew health care was so complicated?” Well, everybody knew.
Remember, most people are covered by their employer’s health care plan. The ACA targets others who do not make enough money to afford decent health care insurance. Upper middle class non-employer covered must buy their own policies.
It’s a complex formula, as all attempts to solve complex problems turn out to be. The Republican plan wants to solve the problems by getting rid of the ACA formulas and opening up the market to insurance companies by helping them to not have to cover older Americans who tend to use the health care system more frequently.
It frees younger people from the ACA mandate (which makes that plan economically feasible) by eliminating the mandate. In its place there are tax credits based upon age for those making up to $75,000 a year. Those credits don’t come close to paying for insurance, however.
The CBO said that the Republican plan would make insurance so unaffordable that older people would be forced to go without, leaving mostly the younger, healthier people to join insurance plans. There would be lower premiums to encourage this but not if the older people were buyers.
This results, the CBO estimates, in 25 percent lower premium for a 21 year old, 8 to 10 percent lower for a 40 year old, and 25 percent higher for a 64 year old. Wonder why older Americans would drop out of the market?
That 64 year old earning $26,500 after subsidies pays $1700 under the ACA; his costs would be $14,600 under the Republican plan. And, the level of deductibles that you must meet before insurance kicks in will be up to the insurance companies. And you know how generous they are.
So if you are older, or plan on getting older, beware of the Republican replacement for the ACA.
Lower prices, the Republicans claim, will come with increased competition. But the CBO analysis refutes the claim that there would be more competition.
The Republican plan says you do not have to buy insurance. Government should not make everyone buy insurance. Even though I do believe that government makes you buy car insurance, making it profitable for insurance companies. Do Republicans want that mandate gone too?
As our president says, it’s complicated. The ACA does need reforms but Republicans have ignored this avenue for years. Now they have a plan. And it’s a killer.
Richard Fulton is an emeritus professor of political science.
