City Council denies Elks’ special use request

FILE PHOTO
The Maryville City Council on Monday denied a special use permit request that would have allowed the local Elks Lodge to move its headquarters to this former church building in the 900 block of East Third Street.
The Maryville City Council on Monday took action on a couple of zoning issues, rejecting a special use permit request from Elks Lodge 760, which had expressed an interest in acquiring a former church at 921 E. Third St. for use as a new lodge facility.
In a separate action, the city’s governing board accepted a similar petition from Northwest Missouri State University for proposed expansion of its Alumni House at 640 College Avenue (West Fourth Street).
In voting down the Elks’ request, the council sided with neighborhood resident Nicki Samson, whose house and yard adjoin the old Assemblies of God church to the northeast.
Samson strenuously opposed allowing the Elks into the single-family zoned neighborhood before both the council and the city’s Planning & Zoning Commission, mostly because she objected to the fraternal organization’s plans to operate a bar and serve alcohol at special events.
The council denied the Elks’ request on a 3-0 vote after members Tim Shipley and Jerry Riggs, both Elks, excused themselves from the discussion on the recommendation of the city attorney and left the chamber.
That left a bare quorum of three council members to decide the question.
Mayor Jason McDowell, who acts as a regular at-large council member for purposes of voting, said he actually made up his mind on the issue when it was debated at the last regular session two weeks ago. He added that, in his view, the Elks Lodge simply wasn’t a “good fit” for the neighborhood.
Councilwoman Rachael Martin agreed, saying that since a special use permit is subject to terms and conditions set by the city and can be revoked at any time, she wasn’t sure a “yes” vote would have been in the Elks’ best interest.
She said a subsequent council could revoke the permit, leaving the lodge without a home.
The third “no” vote came from Councilwoman Renee Riedel, who defended her stance by saying the city “has zoning for a reason” and should not make exceptions to its own rules lightly.
Riedel, who like her four colleagues voted for amending an existing special use permit to allow for an addition to the Northwest Alumni House, noted that neighborhood residents there had voiced no objections.
As for the Northwest project, Vice President of University Advancement Mike Johnson said Monday night that the project is to be largely funded by a $1 million grant from the Walter and Suzanne Scott Foundation of Omaha, Nebraska, and will consist of about 10 new offices and additional off-street parking.
City officials told the council that the proposed addition to the elegant, brick structure — already classed as a non-conforming use in the single-family neighborhood hugging the south edge of campus — will nevertheless meet existing requirements related to yard setbacks, gross floor ratio, height, and ground coverage.
Off-street parking on the property will increase from six to 20 spaces.
