Skip to content

Logic of American campaigns

Richard Fulton

Elections in America have tended to be contested either as a contrast between “progressive” candidates and issues and “conservative” candidates and issues or contests between the character and background of two individuals.

I have been thinking lately that in many ways the present presidential election campaign has become a mixture of the two approaches. The vice-presidential debates brought this into focus.

Certainly Tim Kaine represented by and large the “progressive” ideas and policies of the Democrat party but focused positively upon the candidate, Hillary Clinton and negatively upon Donald Trump. But Mike Pence highlighted the “conservative” position of most Republicans and seemed to want to deflect attention from the character and background of Donald Trump while attacking Clinton.

Perhaps as many pundits are saying, Pence was courting the conservative Republican base for a viable presidential race in four years. On the other hand Kaine was trying to win his place as vice president.

As Kaine continually, and irritatingly, interrupted Pence to quote Trump-isms and ask if Pence could defend them, Pence quickly brought each topic to either an attack on Hillary’s progressivism or a defense of core conservative issues.

Pence is a mellow guy who comes across as your great uncle, but he is a hawk on defense and international affairs—a core conservative value. Even though defense spending is at an all time high and greater than the next 10 country defense budgets combined, he wants more.

Defense spending is big in conservative Republican circles because the defense industry is dominated by huge corporations.

A theme of conservative Pence was that progressives want big government and ruin the economy with over spending and regulations.

Perhaps conservatives should stop attacking progressive Obama’s failed economic policies long enough to see what the world’s independent economic monitor, the OECD, has to say about that.

It reported recently that “the US economy has rebounded: output has surpassed its pre-crisis peak by 10%, robust private sector employment gains have sharply reduced unemployment, fiscal sustainability has been largely restored and corporate profits are high.”

When Pence attacked the deficit he forgot to mention that the Committee for a Responsible Budget, a conservative think tank, has said that Trump’s economic plan would add $5.3 trillion to the deficit in the next 10 years. Clinton’s, they said, would add $191 billion but also add $1.1. trillion in revenue.

While I can’t help note these discrepancies, the point is that Pence was making the conservative arguments in domestic and foreign policy areas, not particularly defending Trump except in the broadest of contexts.

He does this because Trump is the ultimate individual candidate in American politics. He is conservative in the broadest sense but varies from GOP conservatism.

Certainly, elections in America have progressively turned upon individuals who have more support for their candidacy from interests that are progressive or conservative than from their respective party organizations. Note who sponsors so many ads for the Missouri governor and US senate candidates especially.

And because parties have limited resources, Hillary Clinton and even rich Trump uses respectively progressive and conservative issue based monies and support.

Only after the elections do the office holders turn to party labels as a way of organizing for the purpose of governing. Though Missouri and U.S. legislators have shown that legislative Republicans often have split along conservative-ultraconservative lines while Democrats split on geographic lines.

Individuals are the targets of campaigns, each side often trying to define their opponent’s character as negatively as possible. Progressive and conservative views may play a role but too often get lost or horribly mischaracterized in the process.

Conservative or progressive views propel the individuals when they are in office, however, even as they get muddled in the vitriol of a campaign.

Leave a Comment