Glad to be right where I ‘belong’

Matt Pearl
It hit me like a bolt of lightning this past week — a revelation while I was driving on U.S. 136 from Albany to King City, between Carmack and Stanberry. It hit me why I’m happier as a publisher than as a teacher.
I am proud of my years as a teacher, and I know I did things beneficial for my students. But I had shortcomings as well, and I freely admit to being far from perfect.
The revelation was simple enough: I’m a product guy, not a process guy.
If things get done well, I don’t care how. It’s a necessity in the publishing field. I have folks with varying skills hired to do jobs, and as long as the work gets done by deadline, I don’t care about the process.
Not so in education.
Teachers are evaluated almost exclusively by their districts on their process. How a person teaches is now the focal point, and the end product has become of somewhat less interest.
The rationale behind this is pretty easy to figure out.
We have made test score goals in this nation so unattainable that it became depressing to focus on student learning and performance — so in evaluating teachers, we turned to looking less at what kids can do after exiting school and more upon what teachers are doing while the students are still in class.
There’s never any 100 percent guarantee to a teacher that students will perform on test day, but schoolscan certainly use teacher evaluations to look for which teachers they believe are using the best methods to present the information to students.
The result is that schools lose product people like me.
Student scores didn’t worry me, because I could teach a kid how to beat a test. ACT was my favorite area of focus, and I feel I helped several kids do better on this crucial college entrance assessment.
But the Good Lord rescued me, you might say. I now happily work in the real world, where the quality of your product outweighs what your particular process is.
How many of you care how we put this paper together every week?
What if a week went by and we didn’t put one out, but we assured our readers that we were doing everything right within the office?
Would our process be enough to make you feel better about not receiving your paper, our product?
No.
So now I am where I belong. Public education served me well for 13 years, but as you can tell by reading, the prevailing trends in education go against the grain of my thinking.
My warning as a product guy to the process people: The world needs both of us — but education can’t afford to lose all of its “end result” folks. It does teachers no good to reward their day-to-day proficiencies if their end results fall short of academic expectations.
And people like me need to remember that the process we use to produce things needs attention, too.
If we run ourselves ragged around the newspaper office because we’re inefficient and can’t get our process streamlined, then our product will suffer.
But it’s pretty tough for any single one of us to commit totally to both aspects of work: process and product.
Education always breathes in, then a decade goes by and it breathes out again. The pendulum swings, and attitudes change over time.
For now though, I think publishing is where this guy belongs.
