County seeks settlement for century-old bridge
A 100-year-old bridge damaged last fall when a tractor hauling a wide load attempted to cross Honey Creek in extreme northwest Nodaway County is causing headaches for the County Commission.
South District Commissioner Robert Stiens, who has made a specialty of dealing with issues related to rural road and bridge maintenance, said the incident occurred when an MFA employee working out of Iowa attempted to cross the bridge, which is located on a dirt road — 120th Street — that continues east from the terminus of Highway 246.
Stiens said the driver was hauling an anhydrous ammonia applicator that was too wide for the “high-trestle” bridge, which is supported by a network of steel beams rising above the level of the driving surface.
The applicator damaged the beams, Stiens said, significantly undermining the span’s structural integrity. It has been closed ever since.
Stiens said the bridge is damaged beyond repair and will have to be replaced, a project with an estimated price tag of $300,000.
Other, much newer, bridges provide residents with reasonably nearby routes across the creek, Stiens said, so replacing the structure is not an immediate concern. But it is an inconvenience.
So the county has been in touch with MFA’s insurance company, Nationwide Agribusiness, which is not thinking in terms anywhere near the commission’s estimated replacement cost.
According to a letter to the commission from Nationwide’s Patrick Rohrs, the bridge has a total deck area of 656 square feet. Rohrs stated that Nationwide checked with the Missouri Department of Transportation, which provided “cost guidance information” valuing construction of a similar type at $98 per square foot, including demolition of the old bridge.
Ninety-eight dollars times 656 is $64,288.
But, Rohrs continued, the century-old bridge has “significantly exceeded its design life” and “arguably, would have no actual cash value.”
Therefore, according to Nationwide, building a new bridge would be considered a “betterment” rather than mere replacement, a level of compensation for which the company says the insured party is not responsible.
Bottom line? Nationwide says it is willing to cut the county a check for $35,000.
Of course, the county has no intention of replacing the bridge with a similar structure, even if using 1915 construction technology were possible.
Stiens said Nodaway’s governing board intends to continue working with Nationwide in hopes of achieving what it considers a more equitable settlement before moving forward with plans to replace the bridge with a new structure designed for today’s multi-ton farm implements.
