R-II awaits Amendment 3 vote
As Election Day begins, Maryville R-II officials are still questioning the impact of Amendment 3.
If approved by a majority of voters statewide in today’s vote, the amendment to the Missouri Constitution would tie teacher evaluations and tenure to student test scores.
The amendment would require public school districts to implement student-performance-based teacher evaluations that would be used to determine if teachers should be dismissed, retained, demoted or promoted.
In addition, the amendment would require teachers to enter into contracts of three years or less and prohibit teachers from organizing or collectively bargaining regarding the design and implementation of faculty evaluation systems.
In order to combat the amendment, the R-II Board of Education unanimously passed a resolution on Oct. 21 in opposition to the proposal.
The resolution passed by R-II calls the amendment “poorly drafted and deeply flawed,” and argues that there will be unintentional negative consequences for teachers.
The resolution states Amendment 3 will prevent school boards from hiring, compensating or dismissing teachers in accordance with local district policies.
Additionally, the school board fears, the amendment will force taxpayers to pay for more standardized tests and require districts to use teacher evaluations for other purposes than improved faculty performance.
“If Amendment 3 passes, it will have a big affect on schools across the state,” said R-II Superintendent Larry Linthacum. “The concept is good, from a real-world standpoint of holding teachers accountable for student achievement on tests. We want students to do well, and holding teachers accountable is a good thing.”
However, Linthacum said the amendment would diminish local control of public schools and force taxpayers to pay more for standardized tests.
“It’s a good concept, but there are just some parts about how they would go about enforcing the amendment,” Linthacum said.
Linthacum gave the example of a struggling third-grade student who is placed in a classroom based on his or her connection with the teacher.
“It changes the mindset of a teacher, so they might feel they are competing with each other,” he said. “If they feel their pocketbook is tied to how well kids do on the tests, it could cause a dissension. The concept as a whole makes sense in some parts, but overall as a district, we are in opposition to the amendment.”
One of the biggest negative impacts would be on teacher tenure, Linthacum said.
“I know some people feel if they don’t have tenure in their jobs, why should teachers,” Linthacum said.
Linthacum said a major misconception is that Missouri’s tenure law protects bad teachers.
“I completely disagree with that,” he said. “We feel we have great teachers. We realize all of us could get better. We don’t feel our education system is broken. Amendment 3 is one spoke of the wheel from the mindset that our education system is broken and needs to be turned upside down. Getting rid of teacher tenure is one other component that would completely turn the system upside down. We disagree with that.”
If the amendment passes, Linthacum said the district would have to adjust some of its standards, although the district’s teacher evaluation system is already on track to comply with the proposal.
“We feel pretty confident that our teacher evaluation system is good,” Linthacum said. “Traditionally, teacher evaluations have been a hiring and firing method, and we’ve changed it to be more of a growth model. Whether the amendment is passed or not, we’re in the mindset that we hire good teachers, and we are going to try to retain, develop and grow our people. Even if it passes, we won’t change from that mindset.”
The current teacher evaluation law states that all districts must have seven principles included in teacher evaluations. Effective evaluations must include student measures, meaningful feedback, evaluator training, use of evaluation results, clear expectations, differentiated performance levels and a probationary period.
Building on those seven principles, districts can create their own evaluation models.
“We have those seven principles, and we are working on a growth model to help our teachers identify how they can get better,” Linthacum said. “That’s a process that all schools are required to do, and it’s positive and helping us improve.”
If the amendment were to pass, much of the current system would go by the wayside, and student assessment would be the primary method of teacher evaluation.
Although the R-II board opposes the amendment, Linthacum said the district would do its best to comply if the measure becomes part of the state Constitution.
“Our next step would be to work through Jefferson City and the Missouri Association of School Administrators to see what we need to include,” Linthacum said. “We want to follow the laws and make sure we’re doing our job. If the vote of the people says the amendment needs to pass, then we’ll follow suit and do what we need to do to make sure we’re following the guidelines.”
Linthacum encouraged voters to use their own judgment when marking their ballots.
“I really don’t know if it will pass,” Linthacum said. “I don’t think it will, but I think there are some who feel pretty confident that it will pass. We’ll see the results and go from there. We encourage people to get involved and exercise their right to be part of the solution.”
