Skip to content

Pearls: Giving tech its credit

EDITORIAL MUG: Matt Pearl

Have you ever been frustrated with digital technology? I have. Computers, phones, tablets – at some point each has compelled me to ask myself (but also aloud), ‘What am I doing wrong?!’

But I try to give tech its credit. I compose this column most weeks on a small notebook computer, where I typically sit at my kitchen counter and let my mind wander. That’s convenient, right? Knock out a few hundred words and send it to myself on the wi-fi, and I’m good to go.

With the exception of that ridiculous feature that shuts off the car when I’m sitting at a red light – who wanted that? – I see the value in technology, and many aspects of my life are improved directly because of improvements to tech.

As I am sure most of you noted here less than a month ago, the Missouri Senate passed SB 68, and Governor Kehoe signed it into law. While there were several items on the bill, the standout news from passing was the mandate by the State Legislature that school districts codify policies banning cell phone use during the school day.

So for anyone who misunderstands the bill, your State Senate did not directly outlaw phones: it put into force a law directing your public school to enact a set of rules that at the minimum ban phone use during instructional time, meal times – pretty much any time from kids’ arrival at school until the bell dismissing them.

Some schools are putting phones under lock and key during the day, a measure intended to save the district time policing phones when there are more important educational tasks to pursue. Others have essentially said, ‘If we see your phone, we’re taking it,’ a milder approach, but with the same expectation: that technology remain regulated during the school day per state mandate.

Why? Why are teachers generally applauding this? I know the answer there.

The power of handheld technology is undeniable. Used appropriately, smartphones hold within their scope the potential to put the majority of what mankind has learned over thousands of years into the hands of every student who possesses one. The collective information contained in every textbook that set in your high school locker for all four years cannot come close to that contained in a few routine Google searches.

In short, smartphones hold the potential to be the greatest educational tool mankind has ever developed.

So why are they banned in public schools all over Missouri now? Because instead of using the devices to grow their scope of information, kids use them for social media, games and putting music in their ears.

When I was still teaching in the classroom, phones would show up when kids were texting each other, or when they were checking one another’s Snapchat stories. I never caught a kid using a phone and heard that student respond with, ‘I’m sorry, Mr. Pearl, but I just couldn’t wait until sixth period to find out more about Newton’s Third Law of Motion.’ They were Snapping, texting, jamming out to music, watching YouTube or just plain ol’ cheating on their classwork.

And it’s too bad. Those phones have such wonderful potential, don’t they? What is wrong with mankind, that we develop a tool like the internet, a space where wisdom could grow almost limitlessly, and we use the stupid things to take pictures of our own faces to send to someone sitting seven feet away?

I wish social media would disappear. Incidentally, I have never felt more like a grumpy old man than I do this moment. As an educator, I have long known that phones an unwarranted distraction to my students. Even 20 years ago, I had students on their flip phones who could text just by feeling the buttons on their phones: they didn’t even have to look down at the phone before hitting Send. It feels like it is storming now, but these clouds have been brewing for two decades.

But I keep returning to a sense of regret. What a waste! Powerful, networked tech in the hands of 13-year-olds, and we have to make them put their handheld computers away on account of social media. We need to take a hard look at ourselves, folks, because the phone problem started in the negligence of those of us who have lazy-parented our way to this crisis.

Matt Pearl owns and operates The Tri-County Ledger.

Leave a Comment