Pearls: ‘A little learning is a dangerous thing’

EDITORIAL MUG: Matt Pearl
We just don’t know as much as we think we do.
When I studied the 18th century British poets — yes, I actually studied the 18th century British poets once upon a time — I encountered the work of Alexander Pope, who is in his work An essay on Criticism coined the phrase, “a little learning is a dangerous thing.”
Truer words, my friends, truer words.
We know nothing about something, but then we tend to learn a little bit about it and believe we have unlocked all of something’s secrets. We watch a few football games, for example, and think we’re ready to coach — maybe even play — the game on the world’s largest stage.
A little bit of that learning, maybe a few YouTube clicks of sports commentators and pundits feeding us their ideas, and we get smug. We make predictions. We gloat when 1 possession out of 10 the team runs the play we predicted.
But it takes years of experience, exposure to the elite players and coaches of the sport, before anyone can really claim the role of an expert. It was true in 1709 when Alexander Pope observed it about society and the critics of his day — the ones whose commentaries on literature and theatre (the primary forms of entertainment of Pope’s time) — and it’s just as true now:
‘A little learning is a dangerous thing.’
I have been guilty. Most of us have. We read or hear something from this source or that commentator, and we think it sounds good, so we form a fast opinion. But in the process, we don’t vet our sources, meaning we don’t check for authenticity or possible ulterior motives from said sources.
Bias is everywhere, and precious little of what we call facts are indeed indisputable truths. Most of us have not developed a habit of, after reading an article or hearing a sound byte pertaining to an issue, intentionally seeking out another possibly opposing perspective on the matter.
No, most generally we choose to complain about the differing points of view that our news sources seem to possess, and lament the days when St. Walter of Cronkite never uttered a hint of bias about anything. MSNBC and Fox News can’t agree on anything, which shows that each comes a the news from a different starting point — but what else does it show?
It has proven that seemingly contradictory facts can be simultaneously true.
It has proven that just because one network or the other has a starting point more aligned with my own does not mean that said network is always right. Unless you always think you’re right I guess.
We as a people are frequently lacking in basic self-awareness, the quality that, among other things, should remind us that we err by our very nature. People who have talked for decades accidentally call a chess match a mess chatch. People who have been carrying things for their entire lives still drop a plate once in a while, and we who have been right so many times continue to make mistakes.
Whether or not you ever actually admit you’re wrong, you have been wrong at some time. I’m wrong so often, I have begun to celebrate the handful of times I could prove that I was right.
I told a friend my team would win the Big Game 42-24. I was close on the score, but not the winner. Wrong again. That one hurt.
The worst part is that when we acquire that ‘little learning,’ we invoke that very ‘dangerous thing’ of which Alexander Pope was writing. We invite the idols of self-righteousness, the worship of our own minds, to steer us toward a false confidence, a religious-type belief in our own understanding of things we just learned about the day before yesterday.
So let’s read up on everything before we start social media prophesying, huh? Maybe 2-3 articles from different sources on a topic before you start calling people out on Facebook? We might find another humbling adage, this one from Albert Einstein, to be true as well:
‘The more I learn, the more I realize how much I don’t know.’
Matt Pearl owns and operates The Tri-County Ledger.
