Pearls: Would it have changed the outcome?

EDITORIAL MUG: Matt Pearl
The heat of the summer isn’t quite here yet—at least not the worst of it—so I haven’t yet seen a single lightning bug (or firefly, depending on your upbringing). But by the Fourth of July, they’ll be everywhere.
I remember catching them when I was a kid. I’d finally trap one, and a time or two I put it into a jar to use as a nightlight.
‘It won’t live very long,’ my mother would tell me. ‘Yes, it will!’ I would protest. And I would put grass and a couple of sticks in the jar to mimic the bug’s natural environment, believing in my seven-year-old mind that making that glass jar into an insect terrarium would keep the lightning coming for days to come.
I don’t think a single bug lived through the night to the morning.
And when that lightning bug’s little luminescent tail was extinguished, I would feel bad that it was dead. Maybe if I had let him fly around and sleep in his home the night before, the little guy might have lived on for a while.
Maybe. Or maybe bugs just don’t live that long, and his little life would have ended somewhere in the grass or the trees, rather than in my mason jar.
We know so little, don’t we? We think, we act, we make the decision—and then we lock in an outcome. But on any of these little decisions we make, do we every really know what the outcome would have been had we acted differently?
A few days back marked the 14th anniversary of the car accident that kept my father from returning to his role as publisher of our newspaper. That wreck happened because for a one-second window I was driving on a certain stretch of highway while a vehicle traveling on the perpendicular road missed the stop sign and hit me. A second earlier, I would have hit him. A second later, he’d have missed us entirely.
Had the situation been different, my father would not have been injured so severely—or possibly not at all. The script of our lives—mine, my wife’s, my dad’s, my mom’s—would be completely different.
I don’t dredge up the details of that day just to wallow in one of my worst memories. But life’s moments make a difference, a reminder I received during the wreck. In the days following, however, I have reflected upon the incident, and one inconvenient truth keeps hitting me in the face:
I cannot say that I know with 100 percent certainty that things ever would have been better (or worse) today if yesterday had gone differently.
And none of you can say that you know what life would be if you had in the past made different decisions. Whether you believe it to be a blessing or a curse, you and I don’t have the ability to see multiple futures—we can’t know for sure what would have happened had we taken a different path. We can’t know that different path would be better, worse or possibly about the same—all we know is that it would have been different.
Maybe I’m self-justifying. Maybe I murdered those poor little lightning bugs, and in the years following I created a reason not to feel so bad about putting a free creature into a Ball jar, where its life was gone in just a few hours.
But I don’t think so. Think about it: should we live our lives regretting every past decision? Should we assume so frequently that we made bad choices yesterday, and in doing so assume that we should be living better lives now? What about the positives? What about the little things we did right, the seemingly insignificant moments when we chose a path that brought us to success or happiness?
We don’t know how long the lightning bugs will live on one of those summer nights. I don’t catch and capture them anymore: I trap them, show them to the kids, and then let them fly. Do they live longer as a result? I can’t know that. Do I enjoy them better when I catch and release them? Yeah, I think I do.
Matt Pearl owns and operates The Tri-County Ledger.
