Scammers sending couriers for cash

Scam series: Couriers
MARYVILLE, Mo. — On Aug. 3, 2023, a woman stepped off a plane in Kansas City. She rented a vehicle and headed to Maryville, where she wanted to “see the environment” because she’d heard it was a “quiet place,” she would later tell police and the FBI. But law enforcement officials say the woman, Jiahong Pan, was there to further defraud a Maryville man as part of a long-term “pig-butchering scam,” as the FBI calls it, that had already cost him about $190,000.
But Pan wasn’t the butcher, and she certainly wasn’t the pig, either — she was the knife.
Police say she was an intermediary, a courier sent to fetch more than $106,000 in person, likely the final cut to bleed their target dry.
That’s what made the scam so rare, Maryville Police Sgt. Adam James told The Forum. To date, it’s the only local case that he and Detective Ryan Glidden are aware of where someone has come to physically pick up cash used in a scam.
But it’s part of a growing national trend — so much so that in January, the Federal Bureau of Investigation made a public service announcement warning of scammers using couriers to retrieve cash and precious metals from victims of tech support and government impersonation scams.
“The FBI is warning the public about scammers instructing victims, many of whom are senior citizens, to liquidate their assets into cash and/or buy gold, silver, or other precious metals to protect their funds,” noted the announcement. “Criminals then arrange for couriers to meet the victims in person to pick up the cash or precious metals.”
From May to December 2023, the FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center saw an uptick in this activity with aggregated losses of more than $55 million, the agency estimated.
SCAM SERIES
This is Part 3 of The Forum’s yearlong series about scams. With the ever-evolving nature of scams, new AI tech and faster communication, people of Nodaway County and northwest Missouri are falling victim, losing more than a million dollars to scams over the past five years.
The Forum is diving into the specifics of some of the most prevalent scam types being used in Nodaway County today, red flags to look out for and what local law enforcement, businesses and financial institutions are doing to stop the scams before they happen.
Part 1 was published Jan. 4 and offered information from local law enforcement and banks about the millions of dollars that may have been stolen from Nodaway County residents.
Part 2 was published Feb. 15 and provided information about sextortion scams.
Chasing the carrot
In the Maryville case, it involved cryptocurrency investments. According to the probable cause statement, it started with small amounts. The victim met someone online who went by “Lisa Park,” and she told him she had a line on some can’t-miss crypto investments — easy ways to make a little cash, as long as you have the right data, she told him.
Capt. Austin Hann, of the Nodaway County Sheriff’s Office, who did not work on the case, told The Forum that generally, people can usually tell when something seems off and sounds like a scam. But, there’s always that carrot dangling in front of them, tantalizing them with the possibility that it could just maybe, possibly, be true.
“What I tell people all the time is, (scammers are) very good at what they do,” said Hann said. “I mean, that is what their job is. And when they get off the phone with you, or send that email to you, they go right on to the next person. And they do that all day long, and they make a living doing it.
“They’re professionals, they’re very good at it.”
In this case, the dangling carrot was a fake website that facilitated the victim’s crypto trading. The victim would transfer in some money from his bank account, and then he’d see his “investments” paying out a return on the bogus crypto trading site.
According to police, it started with $5,000 to purchase Etherium, a type of cryptocurrency. Selling the coin a short time later netted him $1,088, she told him. Sure enough, his account on the fake trading website showed he was $1,088 richer. Another trade made another $1,200, and he was off to the races — it was time to “fatten the pig.”
A few trades later and the man from Maryville had seen his account on the fake crypto trading site swell to more than $900,000, he told police. That’s when he realized it really was too good to be true.
When he attempted to transfer some of his newly made profits back to his bank account, the transaction wouldn’t go through. Park told him it was because he had to pay $106,300 in capital gains taxes before the transfer could be completed. No problem, though — she would send someone to Maryville to pick up the tax payment in person.
The victim called the police.
When Pan arrived in Maryville, the victim — along with Maryville Police and the FBI — were waiting for her. She was arrested in the Walmart parking lot while still on the phone with the victim, the probable cause statement said, where she was preparing to make the exchange.
House calls
Sgt. James noted that this quick apprehension is apparently quite a rare feat because historically scammers prefer to get funds out of their victims from a safe distance, utilizing shipping facilities or gift cards.
Matt Gaarder and Stef Nickell spoke to The Forum late last year about the shipping side of scams and how they’re always on the lookout for people who may be under the influence of a scammer on the phone or sending large quantities of cash.
“When we get to that level, Stef will Google Map the address to see if it’s legit,” Gaarder said.
On more than one occasion, he said, they’ve found that the shipping address is just an empty lot, an outbuilding and a mailbox standing at the end of the driveway.
“That’s all that was there,” he said. “They will use that address because they know FedEx is just going to drop the package, either put it in that mailbox or drop it right there at that garage. The scammer’s probably sitting across the street. … As soon as FedEx goes, they grab the package and boom, you’re never going to catch them.”
Nickell said that she enjoys doing this type of investigative work, but that they don’t talk to the customers about the possibility of a scam until they’re fairly certain and they will often contact law enforcement to explain the situation.
“We want to make sure,” she said. “So far, I’ve never been wrong.”
Gaarder said that he hopes people will just understand that a government official, law enforcement agent isn’t going to ask for cash to be sent.
“What I would say is, if you’ve never met the person in person and talked to them face-to-face and they’re asking for a large amount of money, I would use that as a red flag and call somebody else for some advice,” he said.
Gaarder said they’ve spoken to people trying to ship cash that have been told to tell the shipping business that they’re sending coloring books to their grandchildren.
Sgt. James said he’s not sure if it’s because scammers are becoming more aware that shipping centers are on the lookout that they’re beginning to use intermediaries to make pickups.
“This also opens the possibilities to victims being harmed physically or, worse yet, possibly killed,” he said. “… Simply, you should never allow anyone to come to your residence to pick up cash. … Law enforcement is also the best and quickest tool. We are here to help, and are more than willing to take calls and meet with people to help ensure the legitimacy of the situation. Most importantly, if a person says ‘do not contact law enforcement,’ or even your family for that matter, it is a scam.”
He believes scam education has increased and as law enforcement and more people are paying attention, scammers’ tactics have had to change.
While there has only been one reported case of a scammer arriving in person to pick up cash from the victim in Maryville, MPD is also aware of two other recent cases just north of Nodaway County in Iowa where a money courier arrived at the victim’s residence and departed with large sums of cash.
James wrote in an email to The Forum that MPD also had a case where an elderly female was scammed out of $52,325, of which they were able to recover $44,000. After helping her to change her phone number, the scammer had the address from which she sent money and contacted a local taxi service requesting a ride from the address of the victim.
When the taxi arrived and no one came out of the residence, the driver called back the number and the scammer answered, explaining there was a family emergency and wanted the driver to make contact with “their grandma” at the residence. The driver did so and when the victim took the phone and heard the voice of the scammer, she immediately recognized it, became very frightened and calling 911.
“As hard as it may seem, don’t trust anyone outside your close circle,” James said, further suggesting that people check and verify before sending any large sums of money anywhere. “Don’t be embarrassed or feel that your question or situation is too small to seek help for. Law enforcement is always available to assist in providing advice or verifying a situation to limit, or hopefully eliminate, the chance you fall victim to one of the many scams.”
