Column: About your bones & cartilage

Frank Grispino MOT, OTR/L, CHT
Would you eat hair to treat baldness? Read on and decide if you should take glucosamine and chondroitin to treat osteoarthritis.
The place where two bones meet and movement happens, is known as a joint. Cartilage is a springy and slick structure attached to the end of bones that in this case, acts as a cushion and gliding surface between the two bones of a joint. When cartilage is intact and a joint is healthy, movement is smooth and pain-free.
When something in that formula is off, damage occurs to the cartilage and pain and dysfunction follow. Cartilage is susceptible to mechanical breakdown from use, abuse and many other reasons. The bottom line is the destruction of the articular cartilage causes osteoarthritis. When an orthopedic surgeon tells you your knee is “bone on bone,” they’re saying your cartilage spacers have worn down and now the bone is grinding on bone, not slick and springy cartilage. When bone rubs on bone, it makes more bone. Usually jagged and rough surfaces. This can cause intense pain when the joint moves.
One of the amazing characteristics of bone is it heals and remodels very well. Cartilage doesn’t heal very well. At this point in time and science, one of the most effective treatments is total joint replacement. This takes the jagged bone and ineffective cartilage out of the equation. The procedure replaces both ends of the bones in a joint with synthetic materials, usually metal and plastic. With the removal of diseased bone and cartilage, movement can happen without pain.
Scientists look for ways to improve the pain-free movement formula with less invasive techniques than the brutal body carpentry that is a total joint replacement. One of the options pushed in the marketing world and sometimes the doctor’s office are supplements known as glucosamine and chondroitin. Does it work?
Glucosamine and chondroitin are building blocks of articular cartilage. We are being asked to believe that ingesting these components of cartilage will result in them being broken down, absorbed through the digestive system, sent through the circulatory system, and then reassembled into cartilage in a knee or hip joint. On the surface, this sounds like a non-invasive and cheaper way to ease the pain of an arthritic joint. When applying simplified science, does that happen? The answer is no.
Let’s apply the statistics. There have been many scientific studies researching the benefits of glucosamine and chondroitin supplements and potentially rebuilding articular cartilage. A meta-analysis is a study that studies results of multiple studies. No meta-analysis has shown that the basic science rules don’t apply, and that cartilage can be healed by taking glucosamine and chondroitin. Individual studies may vary, but I would caution these studies are poorly designed, purposefully misrepresented or the results of placebo effect with regards to pain control. Joint space doesn’t change. Cartilage doesn’t rebuild. So, the stats say the same thing as the science. Does it work? The answer is no.
Will taking glucosamine and chondroitin be harmful? Probably not. When asked by patients if they should take it, I usually steal a quote from a friend and mentor of mine, Dr. Roy Meals. Dr. Meals is an orthopedic hand surgeon at UCLA. He is a past president of the American Society of Hand Surgeons. He’s also a former editor-in-chief for the “Journal of Hand Surgery.” All three roles indicate a world class level of knowledge regarding bones, joints, science and research.
His paraphrased quote I usually use for my response is, “Taking glucosamine and chondroitin supplements to regrow articular cartilage is like a man eating hair to treat his baldness.”
