Pearls: Checks and balances equal survival

EDITORIAL MUG: Matt Pearl
Our republic cannot survive without checks and balances.
It may have been the most brilliant foresight that our Founding Fathers held in 1787: the notion that each of our three branches of government possesses the ability to hold the other two in check when the situations requires such.
In 2026, popularity seems to dictate practice. Electability/Re-Electability seems often to hinge solely upon pleasing the majority. That’s why when the state or federal government gets caught in a dispute between its three branches, there’s a system in place to keep everyone honest.
Or at least as honest as government can be.
It has been among conservatives a point of frustration that the Missouri Supreme Court recently made the ruling that the proposed Missouri map that would have redistricted and potentially have added a Republican seat in Congress from our Show-Me State.
The court—five members of whom are Republican appointees and two of whom are Democrat selections—decided that state officials had essentially brushed aside a petition to put the redistricting question to voters. A conservative court seems to believe it was upholding state law, and in doing so, has angered many folks on the right statewide.
Was the ruling correct? I’m not really arguing one way or the other. You see, like each of you reading, I have biases that affect what I want outcomes to be when considering issues of politics. That’s why there are checks and balances: because human beings have shown themselves to be self-interested, and being held accountable to a law-based standard is important.
What I am saying is that it’s pretty important for there to be unpopular rulings made from time to time on cases like this. If five out of seven judges on the Missouri Supreme Court are conservative selections to the bench, then a reasonable conclusion would be that those five judges ruled based upon their interpretation of state law.
So whether or not you got the ruling you wanted, you got the process that we should all want from the highest court in this state. If these judges are willing to inflame virtually everyone who holds the closest political leanings to their own, if they’re willing to take a stand each knew would be wildly unpopular among their typical supporters, then it would appear they did so based upon their views on state law.
I don’t want judges ignoring the law. That seems like a ridiculous statement to have to make, but I think it’s an important one to remember. If I get my way this time because the court allowed the law to be compromised, then what’s going to stop the other side from getting its way next time on another issue when/if the court flips sometime down the road?
Our symbol for equality in this land is the Lady Justice, who is typically depicted as a blindfolded (and therefore, unbiased) woman holding a balanced scale, which symbolizes the way evidence should be objectively weighed in our courts. She also holds a sword, which is a symbol for her power to enforce/defend justice among the people.
When we put aside our desire for justice to be done—something we are prone to do when our side is benefitting from bias or inequality—we are asking for problems. The pendulum swings, folks. Most of us will live long enough to go through a time period where the other side holds the seats of power: we certainly expect justice to be done in those times, don’t we?
Well, we can’t have it both ways. Either we dedicate our loyalties to the cause of justice and the law, or we can look forward to troubles and injustices in the days to come.
Better that we lose one decision today than surrender a piece of our republic forever.
Matt Pearl owns and operates The Tri-County Ledger.
