Skip to content

Candidates make cases to voters at chamber forum

GEOFFREY WOEHLK/THE FORUM
Nathanael Schultz, of Bowling Green, was the only Republican candidate who said the federal government should have a strong role in regulating data center developments.

MARYVILLE, Mo. — Candidates vying to represent the Sixth District in Congress tried to differentiate themselves at the Greater Maryville Chamber of Commerce’s Summer Candidate Forum on July 15.

The forum also included the two candidates running for Nodaway County Prosecuting Attorney in the August primary and a candidate for state auditor.

FULL TRANSCRIPT

A link to a full transcript of each candidate’s responses is at the end of this article.

But it was the wide Congressional field that received the most attention last week as all five Republicans and two of the three Democrats on the Aug. 4 ballot made their pitches directly to Maryville voters.

The Republican frontrunners, talk radio show host Chris Stigall and Kansas City Councilman Nathan Willett, framed their campaigns differently — Stigall as a national fight against liberal ideology, and Willett as an underdog against the establishment. The other Republicans — Jim Ingram, a business owner from Kansas City; Cody Oshel, a former pastor who lives in Maryville; and Nathanael Schultz, a business owner from Bowling Green — tried to find other ways to stick out from the pack.

Data centers

Schultz, the only candidate of either party who lives on a farm, differed the most from his fellow Republicans, and sought to drive home the contrast. He said he did not support any exceptions for abortions and is the only Republican candidate who said he believed the federal government should have a strong role in regulating data center construction.

“I would immediately start investigations into these data centers as I don’t approve of them,” Schultz said. “The way that they’re going on, I think that there’s a lot being hidden and a lot of lies going on about them.”

Schultz said the federal government is directly subsidizing the building of data centers and that the White House is pushing their development.

“That gets you, in the House of Representatives, the power of the purse to stop what’s going on, (and) make sure that it’s happening in the right way,” Schultz said. “And I do believe that while we will need some data centers to make AI work, the way it’s happening right now is completely wrong, and we shouldn’t be defrauding the citizens who, through those taxpayer dollars, are funding the building of these things — and that’s an atrocity that I think needs to be fixed right away.”

Schultz also took a swipe at Stigall, referencing a February report from KSDK-TV in St. Louis that said Axiom Strategies has been placing ads in favor of data centers in local media around the state. Axiom Strategies is a powerful Republican political consulting firm based in north Missouri that has ties to retiring Sixth District Congressman Sam Graves and is working for Stigall in this campaign.

The other Republican candidates largely stuck to similar scripts, saying that data center regulation is not a matter for Congress.

“I am very, very much someone who believes the less federal government in your lives, the better,” Stigall said. “I get very nervous when people start talking about a federal standard about data centers, because that starts to take you out of the equation.”

Some counties want data centers, and others don’t, Stigall said.

“And I appreciate both positions,” he said. “But if the federal government takes the position that we’re going to dictate and determine what you will and won’t tolerate, I think that’s a mistake. Your county commissioners and your local officials are your first line of defense if you’re concerned about those things.”

Keeping up with China, Stigall added, will mean more data centers and more power plants, which he said the federal government has regulated too strictly.

On the other side of the aisle, the attitude was predictably different.

Josh Smead, a Kansas City architect and the Democratic frontrunner, said he was in favor of a national moratorium on AI data center development to allow Congress to come up with common sense regulations that could protect local communities. Matt Levine, a TSA worker at Kansas City International Airport and a substitute teacher, largely agreed with that position too.

“I appreciate the advancement, we absolutely need that — America needs to be on the cutting edge of technology,” Smead said. “However, I would be supportive of a temporary moratorium at the national level to pump the brakes on some of these larger facilities, especially, as an example, the one that’s going to be going in here in Nodaway County.”

Communication

Smead stood out on the Democratic side, using the rare time in front of a bipartisan audience to brand all the Republican candidates as “Sam Graves 2.0,” and, when discussing how he will communicate with constituents, invoked the legacy of former Democratic Congressman Jerry Litton, who represented the Sixth District in the early 1970s.

“Every month, he would have a ‘Dialogue with Litton’ — a monthly town hall,” Smead said. “He would bring in people from Washington — at one point he brought in Jimmy Carter. He would either bring in multiple important people from Washington or from the area. He would have a town hall every single month. That’s absolutely something I would be looking to do, in addition, of course, to traveling around to all the various counties.

“Thus far in my campaign, I’ve put about 20,000 miles on the car. I’ve been doing this now for a year and a half, trying to meet as many people as I can. And I know I’ve already had more events like this than I believe Sam Graves has had in maybe the last 20 years.”

Though Graves wasn’t there, he was also a frequent reference for candidates from both parties. Even as the Republicans praised Graves’ work in Congress, they also acknowledged that Graves is known across the district for rarely appearing in person at public events. That was an especially tricky needle to thread for Stigall, Graves’ handpicked preferred successor. The talk radio host stressed that he will also have a significant social media presence to stay engaged with constituents.

“He was not a forward-facing guy,” Stigall said of Graves. “He did the work, I think he did it well, but in 2026, I think my job, if I do it well, is to make you sick of seeing me. Maybe it’s on the phone, maybe it’s on TV, but I promise you, you’re gonna hear plenty from me. Not only physically visiting all 33 counties, but also on places like social media and other places advocating for you.”

Though Willett said he respected Graves’ service over the past 26 years, he pointed out multiple times that he felt it was “un-American” for Graves to announce his retirement and endorse a successor less than a week before the filing deadline.

“The fact of the matter is that the current Congressman only gave 120 days to go across 33 counties and build relationships with people,” Willett said. “They were not trying to have a competitive campaign. They were not trying to let a candidate come in there and build relationships that are needed in our communities. And that’s absolutely disgusting and un-American.”

Meet me in St. Louis

Though both parties were on stage at the same time, cross-party sniping was minimal, save for an exchange that occurred several minutes apart between Stigall and Smead.

In answer to a question about having more of a presence in the Sixth District than Graves, Stigall acknowledged that the district, which stretches across the northern portion of the state, is large, and so different parts of the district may have different feelings about how present their Congressman is.

“And so the priority has to be physically being on the ground, and we have committed to at least visiting twice a year every county,” Stigall said. “I think that’s easily achieved, it’s just a matter of, I think — literally we’ve talked about already — if we’re successful after August 4th, fly into probably St. Louis or Quincy and camping out east. Because quite frankly, out east is where, if you talk to folks, they’ll tell you they feel like they’re a different planet from where we are here in the west.”

When it was his turn to speak, Smead needled Stigall over the response.

“All that being said, it’s also worth pointing out to the radio DJ that St. Louis is not actually in our district,” Smead said. “So if you’re gonna camp out there, you’re not actually gonna be in the district. But that’s OK, they’ve been moving the maps around quite a bit.”

And during his response to the next question, Stigall suggested that as a Democrat, Smead should consider leaving north Missouri.

“I wanted to mention to my architect friend from a little while ago there who invoked my name, I am aware that St. Louis is not in the district,” Stigall said. “But you should be aware that that’s largely where you’ll find most of your voters, so perhaps you should move there.”

Nodaway County prosecutor

Two Republicans, incumbent Tina Deiter and David Hershberger, will be on the Aug. 4 primary ballot for Nodaway County Prosecuting Attorney.

During the candidate forum, Deiter, who has been an attorney in Nodaway County for more than 20 years and county prosecutor since 2023, stressed her experience as the biggest advantage, and defended against Hershberger’s assertions that he would make fewer plea deals and seek to go to trial more often.

“I think there’s a little misinformation about — as far as prosecuting attorney — what I can do and what I can’t do,” Deiter said. “One of those I think is important to note is that the main priority of the job of prosecuting attorney is to seek justice. Not just get convictions, but seek justice.”

Deiter said that is sometimes hard to explain and hard to achieve. She also pointed out that the prosecutor cannot file charges that aren’t supported by probable cause, and that the prosecutor doesn’t sentence defendants.

She also contrasted her local background against Hershberger, who recently moved to the area.

“I’m local,” Deiter said. “I’m personally invested in this community. I have been since Day 1. My children have been raised here and … I don’t want to think about it, but I assume my grandchildren will be raised here. … I think that gives you a personal sense of community and a personal sense of being invested in the community.

“I started out as a private attorney, I came here and I did the work, and I walked the walk and did the talk, and here I am. And I think I’m the best candidate for the job.”

Her challenger, Hershberger, has been an assistant prosecutor in multiple counties, he said, in addition to working in private practice prior to moving to Nodaway County. He stressed he would try to take more cases to trial rather than make plea deals.

“When we have reoffending criminals for crimes, it’s an indication that our plea deals… (are) not matching the crime that’s being committed because they continue to reoffend — they’re not being deterred from what they were doing,” Hershberger said. “I believe that’s supporting law enforcement. Law enforcement works long and hard investigating these cases, building the case, getting everything ready to go to the prosecutor — they might spend months in certain cases. I don’t believe there should be anything where those criminals are just immediately turned around, let loose, just to walk the street again.”

In response to a question about what each candidate perceives as the most prevalent crimes in Nodaway County, Hershberger said he largely agreed with Deiter’s assessment of drugs, domestic violence and property theft as the top three.

“And I’ll say, with domestic violence as well — and I put those two together because both of those have a very victim-oriented mindset where someone was either a victim of domestic abuse or they were stolen from,” Hershberger said. “And I know sometimes victims have a different idea about how cases should be handled. But there’s also a third victim in all of these cases, and that’s the state of Missouri and that’s our local constituents. You all pass criminal laws by enacting legislation by picking who your legislators are. So by violating any of these laws, whether you see a victim or not, the community is a victim.

“So I believe … all the cases need to be prosecuted, all the cases need to be brought in order for us to continue having authority and respect for our laws and the rule of law.”

GEOFFREY WOEHLK/THE FORUM
Democrat Josh Smead, an architect from Kansas City, branded all the Republicans in the race as “Sam Graves 2.0.” He said he supports a national temporary moratorium on large AI data center projects like the one planned for Nodaway County.

GEOFFREY WOEHLK/THE FORUM
Nathan Willett, a Kansas City councilman, criticized outgoing Congressman Sam Graves multiple times for announcing his retirement so close to the filing deadline, calling it “un-American”

GEOFFREY WOEHLK/THE FORUM
Chris Stigall, one of the Republican frontrunners in the U.S. House race, speaks during the July 15 candidate forum in Maryville. Stigall, who has been endorsed by outgoing Congressman Sam Graves, said that although he wants to emulate Graves in many ways, he plans to be present in every county in the district more often than Graves has been.

GEOFFREY WOEHLK/THE FORUM
Nodaway County Prosecuting Attorney Tina Deiter speaks during the July 15 candidate forum. She is facing a challenge from fellow Republican David Hershberger in the Aug. 4 primary election.

GEOFFREY WOEHLK/THE FORUM
David Hershberger said he wants to agree to fewer plea deals if he is elected prosecuting attorney and to take more cases to trial. He is facing incumbent Tina Deiter in the Aug. 4 primary election.

GEOFFREY WOEHLK/THE FORUM
Seven candidates looking to represent the Sixth District in the U.S. House of Representatives attended the July 15 Greater Maryville Chamber of Commerce’s Summer Candidate Forum at Rose Hill Acres Event Center. A candidate for state auditor and the two candidates for Nodaway County Prosecuting Attorney also spoke at the event ahead of the Aug. 4 primary election.

Leave a Comment