Skip to content

Forum Editorial: Open doors allow community voices to be heard

EDITORIAL MUG: Editorial art Horizontal

Perhaps the most remarkable part of the opposition to the White Cloud Acres data center project is the wide spectrum of people it has brought together. Members of Nodaway Says No, the grassroots organization that opposes the data center, run the gamut from the most progressive left-wing socialist to the most conservative right-wing MAGA supporter.

We believe that’s because the anger over the data center project runs deeper than objections over how the community’s resources will be impacted, or the possible health effects or artificial intelligence and its uses. Right there in the Nodaway Says No mission statement, it spells out what brings people from such polar opposite political beliefs to a common cause:

“This is not a fight over advancing technology. This is a fight over power and who should and should not have it in our community.”

There is a shared desperation among many at all levels that our voices are being drowned out, that our ability to have a say in our collective future is nearly, if not completely, gone.

In the voices of those who oppose the data center, we hear that desperation. Regardless of the project’s benefits or drawbacks, many of our friends and neighbors have reached their breaking point because the data center is a project that will have generational consequences for our community — and no one asked anyone in the community for their opinion.

Throughout the process, residents have been the last to know about every development. Reliable information has been difficult to come by, and what decisions have been made were made far from here by a faceless corporation working on behalf of one of the richest companies in the world. Can anyone blame those who are angry that no one will even say who the neighbor in our backyard would be?

Our local public officials, for the most part, have been just as much in the dark as the rest of us.

Some have responded by becoming more transparent and more communicative. The Nodaway County Commissioners, whether residents believe they are making the right decisions or not, engage with the public every Tuesday and Thursday morning. The Public Water Supply District board, usually not in the public eye at all, nonetheless moved its most recent meeting to a bigger location, set aside an hour for public comments and then released a draft version of a water resource feasibility study to the public rather than set up roadblocks to prevent the public from reading it.

The Maryville City Council, by contrast, has reacted to increased scrutiny in a disappointing way.

The council has been reluctant to discuss the project publicly, other than to reiterate that the city has little to do with the project other than perhaps provide water. However, the impact on water resources is one of the biggest concerns many residents have about the data center, and Scale Microgrids has made using the city’s wastewater a linchpin of its public relations plan.

Against that backdrop, the council met in closed session on May 11, when even less information was available publicly about the project. In that closed session, according to meeting minutes, three council members held a wide-ranging discussion with Josh McKim, who heads Nodaway County Economic Development, about the data center. It doesn’t take a crystal ball to assume that the council had many of the same questions we all have about how much water the data center would need, and what other data centers are like.

No one begrudges the council asking those questions. In fact, any reasonable constituent would want them to ask those questions.

But not one council member seemed to wonder why that conversation was happening behind closed doors. We find that deeply troubling, especially when so many profess to be champions of transparency. And since The Forum pointed out the closed meeting may have violated state law, the city’s reaction has been only to direct inquiries to the city attorney.

We don’t believe the postponement of Monday’s council meeting was related. That would be a cynical reading. However, council members have done nothing to show that they are interested in the transparency and accountability that is the most basic responsibility of an elected official.

The people of Maryville did not elect the city attorney and they did not elect the city manager. They elected City Council members.

And in this moment when people feel they have so little say in what is happening in their own community, those elected officials have shown nothing but disdain at the very notion that they may not have lived up to their responsibilities.

We hope that when the council convenes again next week, council members will be forthcoming with their intentions and their explanations. They are on the council to answer to those they represent — sometimes literally.

And most importantly, we hope that every member of a public board will be reminded to ask themselves every single time whether they are serving the public better with a closed door, or an open one.

Leave a Comment