Forum Editorial: Plan to replace income tax is no plan at all

EDITORIAL MUG: Editorial art Horizontal
The Missouri House will consider asking voters to eliminate the state income tax through a constitutional amendment that would allow lawmakers to decide how to shift the taxes on income to new sales taxes. The legislature would get to decide how high the taxes would be and on what services, which is the backbone of Gov. Mike Kehoe’s plan.
If you think groceries are too cheap, then this is an excellent plan. If you think gas doesn’t cost enough, then this is an excellent plan. If you think rent, utilities, streaming services, visits to the mechanic and the doctor all are far too affordable as it is, then this is an excellent plan. And if you think schools, libraries and emergency services are all overfunded, then this is truly an excellent plan.
We respectfully disagree.
About 65 percent of the state’s revenue comes from income taxes. According to the nonpartisan Missouri Budget Project, making up that revenue would require raising the state sales tax from 4.225 percent to about 13 percent. In Maryville, that would mean more than doubling the current total sales tax rate, including local taxes, to about 19 percent. That’s without expanding what we pay sales taxes on, which the constitutional amendment would give the legislature carte blanche to decide.
Unlike Gov. Kehoe, we don’t think Missouri small businesses should be saddled with sky-high sales taxes. And we don’t believe many average Missourians think our state government should be focusing on ways to merely match the current funding for public services while making everything more expensive for the majority of Missourians.
Even the local legislators we’ve heard from question why we would take such a drastic step at the same time as the governor is also seeking to overhaul the funding formula for public schools and cut back on property taxes.
Judging by his actions, the governor seems to think our elected leaders should only be responsible for governing high school sports, funding billionaires’ stadium projects and sending any leftover money to private schools in St. Louis.
At the very least, we think the governor could manage it without raising taxes too.
