Council denies two short-term rental applications

City of Maryville logo
MARYVILLE, Mo. — The Maryville City Council on Monday denied two special use permit requests to operate short-term rentals in family residential zones, citing significant neighborhood opposition.
The requests were made by Danielle Erickson, owner of the property at 724 Prather Avenue, and Lisa and Jeff Yosten, owners of the property at 1005 W. 17th St. Several neighbors spoke against the permit requests during a packed council meeting on Monday.
Both homes are zoned R-2 Single-Family Residential. Short-term rentals, like AirBNBs or Vrbos, are allowed by right only in the Campus Town Overlay District and C-2 General Business District. For all other zones, a property owner must apply for a special use permit, which allows neighbors the chance to bring concerns first before the Planning and Zoning Commission and then the City Council.
A petition against the proposal on 17th Street included 40 signatures from nearby residents. The Yostens were not present at Monday’s meeting.
Erickson said she was not aware when she purchased the property on Prather Avenue that it was in a zone that would not allow a short-term rental without a special use permit. She said she wanted to keep the property in good condition long term, and thought that a short-term rental would be better than renting it out to tenants who would likely be college students.
“This is not a party house,” Erickson said. “That is not the market I am targeting; it is not the kind of operation I want to run. My goal is to attract professionals, university visitors and family visiting their college students — guests who are typically quiet, respectful and in town for a specific purpose and a short stay.”
Multiple residents said they were not comfortable with another short-term rental in the neighborhood, saying that guests who stay at the short-term rental at 730 Prather Ave. are sometimes disruptive, coming and going at all hours.
Last week, the Planning and Zoning Commission recommended that the council reject both requests based on feedback from neighbors. The council did just that, unanimously voting against both requests.
According to previous Forum reporting, the two short-term rental permit rejections on Monday are double the number the council had previously rejected since the current system was put into place in 2019 — 12 had been approved and only one rejected over that time.
Other City Council notes
- The council approved a grant agreement to utilize a $530,000 award through the state Department of Economic Development for the purchase of a new fire truck. The new truck would replace Engine No. 3, which was purchased new in 1997. The current vehicle doesn’t meet many modern standards, Fire Chief Jace Pine said, like a cab that is not large enough to fit the required number of crew and small compartments for storing equipment that is bigger than it was 30 years ago. Pine said the grant will cover about half of the cost and that the city is working on a funding plan to make up the rest.
- City Clerk Stacy Wood said that four candidates have filed with her office to run for three City Council seats that will come open in April. The seats currently held by Benjamin Lipiec and Bryan Williams will be up for election on their regular three-year cycle in addition to the seat currently held by Erin Allen, who was appointed in August, a month after the resignation of Tye Parsons. By state statute, Parsons’ seat must go back on the ballot at the first regular election after his resignation, which is this April. The winner of the election for that seat will serve for two years until Parsons’ original term expires in 2028. Wood said that Allen, Williams and Stephanie Campbell filed for the two seats with three-year terms. Lipiec was the lone candidate to file for the two-year vacancy.
- Council members appointed Marta Green to the Maryville Parks and Recreation board. Green will serve the remainder of Rachelle Wilmes’ term which ends June 1.
