Nodaway County crime: Barto Rimel

MF In the News
In the early 20th century, as America was undergoing rapid transformation, an unlikely figure etched his name into the criminal annals of the Midwest and beyond. Barto Rimel — horse thief, escape artist, and later, an inspiration of resilience — lived a life marked by extraordinary twists of fortune. His journey from persistent criminal to respected community member offers a compelling window into the complexities of human redemption.
Rimel was born as Sylvester B. Rimel in Pendleton County, West Virginia, in the later part of the 19th century. He moved with his parents to Nodaway County.
His early life was seemingly unremarkable, and he did not appear in newspaper reports until he began his criminal behaviors in 1905. In April of that year, a carload of cattle was stolen in Conception. There was not much evidence as to who the suspect was until two men revealed to the authorities that they had assisted Rimel in moving the same number of cattle stolen. Rimel was caught by Sheriff Evans in Ravenwood and was charged with grand larceny. Once he was out on bail, he quickly fled the region. He was located in Billings, Montana, after being charged with stealing a horse and, like he had done in Maryville, again fled from the authorities. He then traveled to Wyoming where he continued his crime spree, stealing a horse in Gillette. Rimel was soon captured and pleaded guilty.
He received a sentence of one year of hard labor, but quickly devised a plan to escape the jail. Upon his escape, he stole the sheriff’s horse and headed to West Virginia. He arrived in the state in October of 1905, and by the end of the month, had already engaged in more horse thievery and had been arrested yet again. This time he escaped by setting the jail on fire.
Finally, in March of 1906, he was on the train on his way to prison, but somehow leapt from the train window, while handcuffed. Authorities continued to search for Rimel, and eventually he was found in a North Dakota jail. The Maryville sheriff received word of his location and went to North Dakota to collect Rimel for his original crime of cattle theft in Conception. His trial took place in November 1907, and he was sentenced to two years in the Missouri State Penitentiary. However, before Rimel had completed the entire two years, the governor commuted his sentence, and Rimel soon disappeared, much to the anger of West Viriginia authorities who arrived at the penitentiary at the supposed end of his prison term so that he could be returned to that state and put on trial there.
This certainly is a long, convoluted story of crime and escape. However, Barto Rimel’s story does not end there. When he reappears in the newspaper records in 1911, it is not as a petty criminal or wanted man, but as an upstanding citizen. He married and divided his time between Montana and Kansas, and he became a local celebrity in both places. Following a double amputation of his legs, he drove a specially designed car on trips across the country and moved through town on an engineered wheelchair that used skate rollers and a platform seat.
The strange life of Barto Rimel was one of hardships and happiness. He made mistakes, suffered from illness, and was loved by his family and his community. His story is one of crime but also of redemption and hopefulness.
Visit the NCHS Museum at 110 N. Walnut St. to learn more about the history of Nodaway County. The museum will have its annual Christmas Bake Sale on Saturday, Dec. 13, from 9 a.m. to noon. Please join us for coffee, tasty snacks and Christmas crafts for the kids. The historic Caleb Burns House will also be open that day from 9 a.m. to noon for tours and will be decorated for “A Country Christmas.” Following that event, the museum will be closed for the winter season until early March.
You can still visit us in January and February on the second Saturday of each month from 9 to 11 a.m. Stay tuned for our slate of programs for the 2026 year! Learn more about the museum’s work on our website, nodawaycountymuseum.com. You can contact us at [email protected] or at 660-582-8176.
