Skip to content

Pearls: ‘Am I my brother’s keeper?’

EDITORIAL MUG: Matt Pearl

Recently, I have thought at length on a line from a story I read many years back. When asked to account for his brother’s whereabouts, the murderous rogue who has just killed his own flesh and blood answers only, ‘I know not: Am I my brother’s keeper?’

And so the generations have passed, and mankind has continued to ponder upon a cold-blooded murderer’s question posed to his Maker. Are we our brothers’ keepers? If we are tasked with tending to our brothers’ and sisters’ wellbeing, then to what extent should we do so? How much is too much? How little before our care becomes insufficient?

From a practical standpoint, it feels as though we should engage our brother’s need when our heart compels us to do so, right? But what about folks whose hearts are filled with greed, and they never desire to give their aid to others?

And what about folks whose hearts break for everything uncomfortable that happens in this world? How do we decide when we’re being too Cain-ish, refusing to care for one another as human decency would dictate? And for that matter, how do we decide when our care has overshadowed our brother’s desire or ability to care for himself and for his own?

I can be overfed. I can be underfed. How can I know where to find that line, the one where I’m just fed?

Can we ever agree how we’re going to differentiate between My conservative side wants to put each of us in charge of making such distinctions by the power of our own hearts. But there’s a realist lurking around in my mind, also, and I am conscious of the desire nearly every human possesses: to have more and to keep what is mine.

And my heart and mind work to collaborate when I consider those in need: my heart hurts to know that hunger and sickness so often overwhelm those in need, and my mind sees that there are opportunities for folks to help themselves, be it through jobs or training or any other various means by which society helps individuals better their circumstances. So the aforementioned collaboration between the heart and mind is often akin to Laverne and Shirley working to share that apartment in light of their obvious differences.

How much is too much Get-off-the-couch-and-get-to work? And how much is too much There’s-too-much-wealth-in-this-country-for-anyone-to-be-poor? And who gets to decide?

Like most of the struggles that we insist on bringing upon ourselves in this country, there’s probably a moderate answer that nobody is particularly interested in pursuing. I feel like that used to be the job of politician: we hired said politician to come up with solutions to problems, and to do so with the hard truth in mind that it takes compromise and concession to create balance.

And we’re also not fair in our assessment of people’s intentions, because we cannot truly see into anyone’s heart. People who begrudge programs like welfare might be top-notch givers in their churches or clubs. People who advocate for more robust assistance programs are not necessarily folks with the highest tax burdens.

These are hard things to discuss, because most of our opinions on the subject are fairly emotionally charged. We know poor folks who do their best, but circumstances have kept them from hitting their stride and making the jump to middle class. We also know middle class folks who see the wealthy thriving and the poor being assisted, and they know that society’s economic wellbeing has long been placed upon the shoulders of that same middle class.

And maybe that’s the practical (if not necessarily the moral) breaking point: if a society’s middle class feels too poor, and that same middle class knows the level of tax burden that has been placed upon it, then we see these How-much-is-too-much arguments start to rise. As to our original question related to whether I am my brother’s keeper, I can say only this: when hungry folks eat, I’m glad they got to do so. I have never desired anyone’s suffering. And if I am ever asked that same question from that same Source, I know I’d like to have a little better answer than Cain had.

Matt Pearl owns and operates The Tri-County Ledger.

Leave a Comment