Arkoe man sees family connection in supernatural housemates

SKYE POURNAZARI/THE FORUM
David Reynolds, a retired art teacher, said one of his first paranormal encounters in his home was when he saw a woman in a black dress appear at the end of the hallway.
ARKOE, Mo. — A clatter from behind stopped us both in our tracks. David Reynolds and I looked at each other.
“Probably the cat,” he ventured.
When we entered the spare room, glass bottles were standing on the floor just as David had left them — but a few were now toppled over.
The first thing I’d noticed when I’d come into the two-story, 1920s farmhouse near Arkoe was how sturdy the floors were. The rest of it was a bit rundown: peeling wallpaper, cobwebs, water damage seeping in from some corners of the ceilings. David told me that was simply because of how expensive it is to keep up a large old house like this one.
When some people walk into a room, they check the exits, or the faces, or mentally count the square footage. I check for cats.
The second thing I’d noticed?
There was no cat in that room.
👻👻👻
‘This is their house’
Early last century, the Barmann family owned and farmed a large acreage here that David said at one point nearly reached Maryville. In the 1920s, when the county moved a road, two homes that had been on separate ends of the family property were moved, too, and joined together to make the one David now calls home.
When his uncle, John Barmann, died in 2015, David moved back to take care of the property and final details. He got the house, but the remaining land, which had become quite a bit smaller over the decades, was divided among family, some of whom still farm it today.
“That’s what I wanted in the first place,” David said. “I spent summers here. Worked here my whole life basically. Summers when I was in school, I’d come here.”
When he arrived in 2015, the house “was in kind of a ruckus,” he said. “You could feel something was going on.” It didn’t take long for him to have his first encounter.
While he was in the dining room, a woman with her hair in a bun, wearing a black dress with a white, frilly collar, was standing by the door at the end of the hall.
“Plain as I can see you,” David recounted to me in the very same dining room. “Then I turned and she was gone.”
Not everyone in the family is a believer in the supernatural. But his mother, Kathryn, was. She told him at the time that she was certain the woman in the black dress was one of their relatives, though she couldn’t be sure of the name.
After the initial couple of weeks, when it became clear he was here to stay, things started to calm down, he said. Now he only experiences something peculiar or notable every couple of weeks.
“That’s just them,” he said. “… It’s just me, the cat and the dogs — and these guys.”
Adopting a self-sufficient lifestyle, David works a garden each year, keeps chickens and goes to town every three weeks or so for supplies.
He has kept the house as similar to the one from his youth as possible, partly, he said, out of respect for the spirits he’s come to believe he shares the home with.
“They’re my family,” he said. “… This is their house. I’m just living here.”
Sharing a home with ghosts doesn’t particularly perturb the retired art teacher, who has filled much of it with his artwork alongside photographs of family.
A self-confessed pack rat, one of the spare rooms contains old filing cabinets filled with records from the farm, family letters, family stationery, bank deposit slips, old cookbooks and more. It wouldn’t feel right to throw any of them away, just in case they’re important to the family who spend their afterlives here, he told me — or, more practically, if something might be important to some future family member interested in the family’s history.
On the main floor, in the dining room, photos of Kathryn’s parents, Paul and Helen, each sit in their own motionless rocking chairs. Opposite the rocking chairs is a wall of family photos, with one conspicuous vacant space where it looks like a photo should be.
David explained the other family members didn’t like the woman in that photo too much. So he’s no longer surprised when, no matter how securely he feels he’s put it back up, the next morning he finds it’s been knocked off the wall.
He hardly bothers putting it back up anymore.
‘I believe in most everything’
While working on an art project in the living room one night around dusk, David saw a second apparition: a short, dark figure who was leaning around the stairs at the end of the hallway by the front door. The figure peeked at him, and then was gone, he said. He thinks maybe it was a child.
He also showed me a bedroom door upstairs that typically sticks closed. I confirmed it — the door certainly wasn’t easy to get open and closed. Then he showed me a video he recorded from the opposite end of the hallway. The door seemed to be closing on its own with no sticking at all.
“Some people don’t believe,” he said. “I believe in most everything.”
Perhaps unsurprisingly, David is a fan of the show “Ghost Hunters.” He even made his own version of a DIY ghost detector out of a mason jar, copper wire and aluminum foil, though he told me it hasn’t detected much yet.
Not all the encounters have been spooky. Some have been much more mundane or even, well, familial.
Footsteps on the stairs aren’t uncommon, he said, and when he turns a Chiefs game or wrestling on the TV, the large French doors leading to the living room sometimes move and rattle with seeming excitement.
While watching television with his youngest son, Austin, one day, they both looked at each other questioningly.
“Do you smell that?” David said his son asked him.
They were both thinking the same thing.
“Granny’s cooking chocolate cake,” David recounted.
The two headed to the kitchen and opened the oven just in case. No cake. But the smell remained.
‘I don’t come up here’
Wired in the 1930s, the electricity in the farmhouse is a bit “iffy,” David told me. Because of that, he keeps half the electricity turned off. He’s even gone so far as to tape over some of the electrical outlets to make sure they aren’t used.
When Austin visits, he stays in the only bedroom upstairs at the front of the house, not in one back by the attic. David doesn’t blame him. He told me that before he moved in, a family member had told him they had seen the attic window was open. When they investigated, the house was all locked up, and no one had been living in it.
“I don’t come up here,” he said while leading me up there earlier this month. “I don’t need to come up here.”
Knocking down cobwebs from the corners of the doorway, David brought me into the small, dark room. The roof is angled, the ceiling and floor unfinished, and a window is almost covered in flies, which struck me as odd.
“This is the attic which nobody wants to go in,” David told me. But it was exactly the place I’d most wanted to go since he’d told me what was up here.
We stepped around some boxes, avoiding a flimsy pull string dangling nearly to the floor from a light fixture hanging from the ceiling in the center of the room so we could get to what we were here for.
Beside rolled up carpets that are original to the house was a box holding two very old dolls that very much looked their age. Except for one thing.
“Why (aren’t) they full of dust?” David said, voicing the observation out loud. “Wouldn’t you think after a hundred years they’d be deteriorated to nothing?”
David doesn’t have an explanation. No one has ever seen the dolls do anything an inanimate object shouldn’t do. But then again, even the skeptics in the family are reluctant to spend much time in the attic.
David said he’s sometimes considered getting the ancient dolls refurbished, but always decides against it because he’s afraid they might fall apart if he moves them. So they remain in the box. While we’re watching them, anyway.
“This is their stuff,” he said of his nonliving housemates. “Everybody’s kinda weird about it, but I’m not.”
I thought it was the dolls that would attract my interest the most in the attic, but it turned out they weren’t.
David told me of another two family members who were working in the field one evening. They called David to tell him the light in the attic was on, “shining bright as day.” One of them lost the ensuing game of Rock, Paper, Scissors and had to go check it out.
“He said that’s the fastest he’s come through the house, looked, (saw) there’s nothing, and left,” David recounted.
I wasn’t sure I understood. So somebody left the light on?
Then he reminded me of the electricity, pointing to the light fixture.
There was no lightbulb.
👻👻👻
I had come back to the house after my first visit to get a few more photos. That’s when the glass bottles fell to the floor.
Yes, I looked for a cat and hadn’t found it. But I also hadn’t gotten down on my knees and looked under the bed. I’ve looked for enough cats in my life to know that they seem to have some supernatural hiding abilities of their own sometimes if they really want to.
So when I left, even though I consider myself open to the paranormal, I couldn’t truthfully say I was convinced. Some dolls looked a little cleaner than I would’ve thought. A trick of the setting sun may have made the attic look unusually bright. An affinity for chocolate cake caused father and son to share a spontaneous craving. An old house rattles occasionally. There’s no shortage of plausible explanations.
I was pretty satisfied with that by the time I got back to the office, when I saw I had a text waiting from David. He’d found the cat.
It had been outside the whole time.

SKYE POURNAZARI/THE FORUM
A rocking chair that once belonged to Paul Barmann, Reynolds’ grandfather, is displayed with a photograph of Paul and his wife, Helen in the home in Arkoe.

SKYE POURNAZARI/THE FORUM
David Reynolds tells Forum staff member Twyla Martin earlier this month about his home while they look at a wall of family portraits.

SKYE POURNAZARI/THE FORUM
Arkoe resident David Reynolds reenacts earlier this month how he says an apparition once peeked at him from around the corner of the stairwell in his home.

SKYE POURNAZARI/THE FORUM
David Reynolds mostly leaves the attic alone, he said. Dangling from the center is a pull string for a light fixture.

SKYE POURNAZARI/THE FORUM
A second old doll keeps the first company in the attic. David Reynolds says that while the two look quite worn, he’s unsure why they haven’t accumulated more dust.

SKYE POURNAZARI/THE FORUM
Dolls in David Reynolds’ attic that he says don’t appear to collect dust. Reynolds told Forum Managing Editor Skye Pournazari about the family spirits that he believes still live in his old family home.
