Skip to content

Pearls: Morality doesn’t have to conform to the times

EDITORIAL MUG: Matt Pearl

Say what you want about religion — it’s certainly your constitutional right to so — but I have a few affirmative words in favor of organized spirituality, and I’ll attempt to do so from a completely secular, practical viewpoint.

I will start with the most obvious, at least to my thinking: the more people there are who agree upon what actions are objectively right and which are wrong, the more likely people are to govern their own decisions using a common set of criteria.

The exception proves the rule: today, we see each person individually attempting to define truth, then each of us simultaneously expecting others to permit ( even agree with) our personal perceptions of ‘fact.’

See, this is the great value of religion from a social perspective: if everyone gets to invent his or her own private set of moral values from the comfort of their own homes, we see divisions forming naturally. Who decides what’s right and what’s wrong?

Again, enter religion – particularly faith that is base upon texts, scriptures and such encoded, time-tested values. When morality is codified, and when enough folks believe that the spiritual texts that provide the source material for their faith are indeed sacred, it allows them to put their private notions of truth aside. People stop trying to invent their own morals based upon their singular set of experiences, instead choosing to adopt the common good and bad of the community.

Does this cause people to live in ways that are at times contrary to their desires? Yes. If your religion lets you do whatever you want, then it’s not a religion: it’s a club. I like clubs, and I like churches, but I’m here to tell you that the two are not the same.

So the problem that always seems to arise among free people when the arguments I have put forth (as well as others like them) are made is that of choice: Who gets to choose which religion is best for the community? And if the freedom to practice religion is guaranteed to all citizens — as of course it is in America — then how can there be consensus of faith?

Is the answer that we adopt a state religion? I don’t think so. What if the state chooses a religion that my heart and soul reject as truth? Where does that leave me? That cannot be the answer.

My observation is that most societies in this world seem to have religious leanings that tend to dominate the general landscape. Christianity, for example, is not a state religion in the U.S., but it’s the most commonly practiced across the majority of the nation. Is it conceivable that communities, states, nations, even empires are somewhat predisposed to view the world in ways that appeal to their constituents?

What can we expect, then, when we see the rates of church attendance, participation and membership fall? You’ll see trends that favor folks endorsing their own individual views on right and wrong. There is virtue in individual freedom, and I have always believed this to be true.

But friends, there is also value in conformity.

Our society believes in conformity, doesn’t it? Go express your most non-conformist view out in public and measure the response. You might end up wishing you’d kept your opinion to yourself, and that’s proof that there is power in conforming to a community standard – even a standard of thought.

Socialism and communism are each examples of social conformity: they are just predicated upon different texts being mankind’s sacred guides – it’s Marx instead of the Bible. All religion requires that we conform; I just happen to prefer the ancient wisdom of the human race to that of central European philosophy. Faith has given so many folks hope, while Marx has generally done little more than offer up kings and czars as scapegoats for the people’s pain and hunger. And it turns our people can starve within communism’s grasp with the same ease – or with perhaps more – as they can under the rule of an unjust leader.

Religion’s power – and I declare this without even a single mention of the Almighty before this moment – lies in large part within the scope of organization of morality. People receive hope from the sacred wisdom of their forefathers, rather than endlessly searching for answers rooted solely within their own experiences and impressions.

Religion is bigger than me, and that’s a comfort. Morality doesn’t have to conform to the times, and mankind doesn’t have to re-decide good and bad as each generation passes. We all conform to something, to someone. I’d rather conform to something proven, as opposed to aligning with the passing trends of time.

Matt Pearl owns and operates The Tri-County Ledger.

Leave a Comment