Skip to content

Pearls: Have faith that we have brighter days ahead

EDITORIAL MUG: Matt Pearl

Can there be two different United States of America? Or rather, since we essentially divided into two major ideological camps, how long can we sustain our specific separation and remain a nation intact?

I used to think we were just experiencing the standard two-party tug-of-war with the left and the right each pulling their hardest for control over the flag in the middle of the rope. One would claim the day now, and the other would notch a victory later, but that flag would consistently remain neat the center of the event.

Now the game has changed. We have a camp of Americans who desire ground-up, fundamental change that would essentially rewrite the past, present and future of the country. The other contingent wishes to allow the USA to grow on its existing trajectory.

Both groups acknowledge the mistakes of the past: one group wants to erase them, while the other believes erasing the past means also bulldozing the lessons we should learn from it.

It’s all very Gatsby-esque: the idea that an individual can repeat the past, rewriting it as he goes, all in an effort to change it into something better than what it actually was. We learn in that novel something we each should have intuitively known: that the past can’t be changed – and we’re fools to attempt to relive, repeat or alter it in any way.

George Santayana told us that, ‘Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.’ Perhaps we may now appropriately continue that thought: ‘And those who erase history remove its power to continue teaching future generations.’

There will always be before us the temptation to attempt to reshape wht world in the image of what we wish for it to be. There is currently an America forged from the actions of our national ancestors, a nation that exists in its current form because the past was what it was: plenty of warts, but plenty of triumphs as well.

There’s another competing America, whose proponents believe that she should be reinvented, reimagined and reformed at a moment’s notice – without any tether connecting it to any absolute truths or creeds. This view asserts that we are a nation that can afford simply to erase its past: there are no answers looking at the past anyway, its proponents might tell you.

Well, I’ll freely admit that there are experiences in my past that cause me pain and shame. By the way, these are the very experiences that continue to teach me the most. If you and I can improve as people by learning from the past, why can’t the collective American Nation do the same?

But let’s get back to the notion of our national division, which I believe now has nothing to do with conservatism versus liberalism at all. Instead, the figurative Mason-Dixon Line in 2025 denotes the separation between two other conflicting perspectives:

Shall we embrace our American values, bond together and face tomorrow – OR Shall we write a future in which change and departure from the past are the measures of progress? I could call myself a conservative, and I guess that would be correct, but neither the conservatives nor the liberals from my childhood were so obsessed with reinventing America as the progressive contingent of today.

I would love to see an America in which everyone felt like a stakeholder, a land where we each felt fulfillment and took ownership. But how can you make every single citizen believe he or she belongs? How can we honestly say that every idea is a good idea? We can’t, because some ideas are flawed, even foolish.

If we want to see more folks feeling enfranchised in the American Dream, maybe a good idea would be for us to agree upon what exactly that dream is. Home ownership? We have our work cut out for us, but we can do that. Opportunity in the workplace? Let’s find affordable ways to train folks for the jobs we have, and then get them working hard and living well. Improved mental health? Let’s put our phones down and show one another that we care for each other.

But we have wasted enough time. Let’s get started doing something special, huh? It’s only bleak if you don’t have faith that we have bright days ahead of us.

Matt Pearl owns and operates The Tri-County Ledger.

Leave a Comment