Skip to content

Forum Editorial: Public notices in newspapers remain vital

EDITORIAL MUG: Editorial art Vertical

Around the newsroom, we’re big on rules, especially ones that are meant to bolster transparency and fairness in our democracy. And it probably will come as no surprise that we also believe public notices in local newspapers are a vital service that could not be achieved as effectively any other way.

Those two beliefs are at odds when it comes to the news that three townships in Nodaway County will not be able to move forward with their road bonds because of noncompliance with public notices.

We encourage you to read the story in this week’s Forum that explains the circumstances, and the story from the Missouri Independent on the Times-Tribune side that goes into detail on how the issue was discovered statewide.

From The Independent’s reporting, it certainly seems like everyone involved understands that to enforce the law in this case only does a disservice to voters. The clerks who opted to give voters more time with election information rather than less, like Nodaway County Clerk Melinda Patton, were acting with the best interests of voters in mind — and it’s hard to argue that voters aren’t better served the way they’ve been doing things, which no one had previously objected to.

At the same time, it is difficult to ask the state auditor to willfully turn a blind eye to a law simply because it doesn’t suit us. Nor should we ask the state auditor to ignore the law simply because he and his predecessors have in the past, or because the secretary of state’s office has apparently been doing so as well in certifying elections that the public did not receive proper notice of.

What everyone can seem to agree on, though, is that the law needs to be changed to be more in step with how the world works today.

However, we caution our state legislators — who are so rarely prone to caution — that doing more than restoring the spirit of the law would only bring more harm to the transparency and fairness it’s intended to encourage.

Last week, for example, New Jersey Gov. Phil Murphy signed a new law that will effectively end requirements that public notices in that state be placed in local newspapers.

Part of the reason, supporters of the bipartisan legislation say, is that there are too few newspapers left to serve the intended purpose behind the requirement.

We acknowledge that newspapers certainly aren’t as big a part of daily life in our communities as they used to be (present company excluded, of course). But they remain the best option for public accessibility and transparency. And public notices serve as a crucial lifeline for the remaining local newspapers that would struggle to stay alive without them.

If sample ballots were all we were talking about, it might make sense to simply require the county clerk to post the sample ballots on the county website and be done with it. Most do that now, anyway.

But it’s not just sample ballots. Advertisements for bids, surplus sales, foreclosures, name changes, certain probate legal cases, tax sales and more — all of them must be posted in the local newspaper to ensure a fair marketplace.

A local contractor doesn’t have to have a prior relationship in place with a school district or other authority in order to hear about a project they want to bid on, and they don’t have to walk into the courthouse, city hall, the health department, the sheriff’s office, the school administration building, etc. every day to check if there are any new bid openings.

Similarly, taxpayers don’t have to check each of those agencies’ websites every day or be involved with them to know what they’ll be asked to vote on. All of it is right alongside all the other community information anyone would expect to find in a newspaper, even if they don’t read regularly.

Additionally, it creates an independent paper trail.

The need for that came into sharper focus from The Independent’s reporting that the law firm handling so many of these bond cases had apparently not actually been checking the affidavits they were submitting actually lined up with when notices ran in newspapers. If the notices were scattered across a dozen agencies, or confined to an obscure corner of a state website that no one would seek out for any other reason, how likely is it that anyone would ever notice when things weren’t done correctly?

In this case, the letter of the law worked against its spirit, and that loophole should be closed. But it would be all too easy to manipulate construction contracts, for example, if only a select few know when and where to look.

Yes, newspapers, like all forms of media, have a more fragmented audience these days than was true 50 years ago. But there remains no better place for matters important to the public to be disseminated.

Requiring public notices in local newspapers is the best way we have right now to ensure a simple, if imperfect, level of transparency and fairness that has the added benefit of keeping local newspapers alive.

The legislature must make it their top priority next session to fix this outdated law that has hurt communities across the state, including ours.

But please, for once, don’t make the problem worse.

Leave a Comment