Pearls: This isn’t Reagan’s America

EDITORIAL MUG: Matt Pearl
An autopsy is a procedure performed following one’s death, the purpose of which is to discover either a cause of death or the extent of whatever illness or abnormality from which an individual suffered at the time of the time of said death. That’s the literal definition.
Sometimes today, though, we speak figuratively about an autopsy or postmortem being performed when an idea, initiative, action or even a relationship fails. Our political parties certainly call for the metaphorical autopsy following a difficult loss, particularly in a critical election cycle.
Regarding the November 2024 election, it would be natural for Democrats to backtrack, to examine the lifeless remains of their hopes for the White House, and work to determine the cause(s) of death. Republicans were doing the same in 2008, 2012 and 2020 – whichever team loses has an investigation to conduct.
Now, what the autopsy reveals should be objective: information is gathered, polls taken, actions and timelines surveyed, with all of it leading to a (more-or-less) factual conclusion regarding what went wrong.
In 2008 and 2012, for examples, I’m sure the Republican autopsy of the election revealed that the left had the more energizing candidate, and individual who demonstrated better electability and represented more positive ideals than his Republican foes – two ‘establishment’ figures who seemed like ‘safer’ choices to the traditional crowd. By ‘safer,’ I mean they spoke in the language of the American moderate conservative, one of the most electable profiles in all the land.
What would the 2024 Democrat autopsy reveal? I wonder if the actual lessons of the election have landed with Ms. Harris and the left.
I look at the election with the eyes of a moderate conservative – I like my progress to come in a slow reveal. Overnight change holds little interest to me, because it’s typically not well thought out. My takeaways, were I to perform part of that postmortem on the losing party, would be fairly straightforward:
Conservatives did not enjoy being called racist, xenophobic, fascist, Neo-Nazi rednecks, so they voted for the side that didn’t call them those things. Did some of them actually fit the descriptions contained in those unfavorable nicknames? I’m sure some did. Does anybody respond positively to being called an idiot? Nobody I’ve ever met.
This is not a remark on individual character. There is no average Harris or Trump voter. Candidates and parties are the aggregate product of respective varied constituencies. One party painted its opponents as backward hillbillies, and the other labeled its foes as woke progressives. And, Americans, as always, decided which of those labels was worse, then voted for the other.
And now, the fallout. Social media is ablaze with the champions of each ideology showing ongoing contempt for the other. Except now, we’ve reversed roles in a notable way, for it was once the liberals who seemed to be endlessly pushing the gas pedal of progressivism, while the conservatives pumped the brakes to keep this automobile we call America from going too fast.
Now, the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) is pushing the accelerator for conservative reform, and it is the left who finds itself manning the national brakes. It would be comical: if our lives and futures were not at stake, that is.
Yes, the right-wing version of progressivism is in full swing, and the left has yet to perform an accurate autopsy on 2024. The cause of death could be Americans delusion or ignorance – but liberals are probably learning at this point that calling half the country ignorant or delusional isn’t going to flip the narrative in 2028.
As for the right, I’m sure it feels like this was the pendulum swing back to political sanity – but we must admit this 2025 democracy is a different beast from Reagan’s America, or even from the great Republican progressivist Theodore Roosevelt’s vision for the nation. And everyone needs to remember that a pendulum obeys certain immutable law of physics; 2024 was a swing to the right that was unprecedented in its force – so we know what must logically follow.
Matt Pearl owns and operates The Tri-County Ledger.
