Skip to content

Guest Columnist: The border as a reflection of ourselves

Last month, I wrote to you about part of my experience traveling to the borderlands in El Paso, Texas and Juarez, Mexico. I quoted the founder of Abara, Sami Dipasquale, who said, “We all have had ‘others’ in our life at some point. The border is rarely the problem. We create borders in our own lives: in our families, in our communities, in ourselves. We see a problem, and we want a simple solution. We look to blame others. The border is a reflection of ourselves.’” I wrote about humanizing others because I believe this is where we are lacking, but I also learned there are myths that exist that further that dehumanizing mindset. I’d like to share another part of my experience.

We read and listen to stories of heroes and villains. Disney, superheroes, “Harry Potter,” “The Chronicles of Narnia,” “Wicked,” just to name a few. For the most part, we always identify with the hero, or protagonist of the story. We view ourselves as the outcast, maybe even the victim, who overcomes all odds and rises above and stands up for what is right. We want to believe in the hardest moments, we will be noble just like our heroes. Reflecting on myself, if I am being honest, I fall short of this. The “humanizing” part is we all do because no one is perfect. But are we losing our ability to discern? Are we losing our ability and desire to be humbled?

When I have had conversations about immigration and the issues at our border, I am most often met with “We need to get a handle on all of the drugs that are coming in here by people who are entering the country illegally.” The notion behind this is true. Let’s find reasonable solutions to stop all of the drugs that are so often deadly and at the very least, dangerous. According to a 2021 statistic report from the U.S. Customs and Border Protection, over 90 percent of both methamphetamine and fentanyl were seized at ports of entry. Furthermore, it was found during the fiscal years of 2019-2024, 80 percent of the people who were caught with fentanyl were U.S. citizens. When we think about drug sourcing, this makes sense. It would be too big of a risk to send someone into the U.S. with a backpack full of drugs who one, cannot lawfully reside here and two, has to climb walls with barbed wire. The smarter decision would be to send someone who’s citizenship will not be questioned and who has the capability to bring back a lot of drugs at once. We also need to look at where the demand for drugs in this country is coming from.

This is the discernment and humility part. This is where it is possible that we are not the heroes of the story, but the villains, or at the very least, a bystander. There are horrible people everywhere, even amongst the most vulnerable. There is no denying that from me. The people I met at the shelter in Juarez- those fleeing from immense violence, extreme poverty, war, and/or persecution- are not responsible for bringing drugs into the United States. They are currently still waiting “in line” (in Mexico) trying to do things legally, who have been cut off by us, with no pathway to legal citizenship. The majority of people here with an expired visa or green card have been waiting on our immigration system to approve them to continue to be here legally. So many have done everything right, and they have been waiting on an answer for years. They didn’t bring drugs to this country with them, rather they are working hard at the jobs we don’t want, they are feeding us and our families, and they are paying into our system while not being eligible to receive much U.S. benefit in return. Going through our immigration system is difficult, to say the least, and it is not set up for success. When immigrants don’t succeed in our system, we do not succeed. We are so concerned about all the crimes “they” are supposedly committing and we say we want “them” held accountable, yet I fail to see much justice done to our own citizens within our own systems of the very crimes we’re accusing “the others” of doing. This notion sometimes leads to immigrants being victimized here in the U.S., and it goes unreported due to the fear of retaliation and/or deportation of themselves. We blame “them” for the drugs, yet simultaneously funding for drug programs, mental health aid, and non profits are being threatened to be cut or have been cut already. And here we are, looking for a simple solution, so we blame others. This is how the border has become a reflection of ourselves.

I believe there are things in life we cannot control, but I also believe we still hold our own pen in our hands and can write how we want our character in our story to change. I understand the issue of immigration is complex. But I am still picking up my pen and starting with myself. I have not always been a protagonist, I will continue to make mistakes, but I want to learn and be a better character in my story.

Meghann Kosman is a victim advocate with North Star Advocacy Center in Maryville.

Leave a Comment