Pearls: Critical thinking is the Kryptonite to biased reporting

EDITORIAL MUG: Matt Pearl
The two most common times I typically compose this column are Monday evenings and Saturday mornings. In a given week, it is nearly always at one of those two times when I sit down to have a one-sided conversation with each of you.
The Monday evening columns generally reflect my fatigue – my frustrations with humanity come to the surface in these writings more frequently than in my Saturday columns, when the coffee is fresh in my veins and my outlook a bit more positive.
Before we go any further, I will inform you that you are reading a Monday evening column – and it’s going to show.
Today’s news cycle centered on Presidents Trump and Zelenskyy, and as anticipated, every social media friend I have is either pro-Trump or flying the flag of the Ukraine on his or her respective online offerings.
And more power to each of them. Free speech is as important to me as any of the rights guaranteed to you and me, and I in no way wish to impede folks from exercising theirs (nor do I wish to insult them for doing so).
But like so many click-worthy headlines of the day, I ask myself whether anyone will ever offer a perspective to me, an individual who tries not to make up his mind about who or what to support on any single issue without reading the facts.
Half the media would like me to condemn Big Mean Trump for insulting his White House guest and seemingly siding with Putin and the invasive Russian regime. The other half reminds me that the Ukraine’s intent to join NATO has far greater-reaching implications that put Russia behind the proverbial 8-ball, a potential catalyst for World War III.
I half believe both of them. I half-doubt most of what the click-fed media feeds me. There’s no commitment guarantee I can discern from any ‘news’ agency whose business model is build on clicks and ‘Likes.’
I publish a small-town newspaper. Folks sign on to subscribe, and they get 52 issues. The number of newspapers they receive is based on their payment: they don’t get more of my news if hey like it better, and they don’t get less of it if they don’t enjoy it. I have, in other words, far less motivation to sensationalize any single story or issue – the folks who bought the paper for the most part have already paid, making the specific content of any single issue the only variable that can affect my sales on newsstands.
I believe that in the news climate of today, I have reasonable cause to doubt any agency collecting instant feedback on its reporting. It’s a wonderful marketing tool, but our increasing national division can, and I believe should be connected directly with the click-counting nature of media today.
I believe that the lion’s share of reporters possess integrity. I believe the folks running newsrooms seek accuracy and accountability for their readers/viewers. I believe in journalism.
I also believe that there are profit-driven individuals in positions of ownership and stewardship of media companies that have every reason to use click data to make decisions regarding which news to use – and which news to use – and which side of the news their consumers want.
As their biases move them further apart, news agencies are taking us with them. We must not let them do it.
Seek to know the truth. If you think you love Donald Trump, find occasions to read a little criticism directed toward him. If you think you hate him, read what he does and look for his logic. If you just read this paragraph and thought something like ‘All the legacy media hate Trump, so I never look at any of it anymore,’ or ‘Trump is a fascist, and there’s never any logic to what he does,’ then I probably just lost you.
But if we all want to find the truth in a sea of clickbait, we might have to take stock of how many facts – unbiased and unsponsored – that we can find, then make our own decisions. Critical thinking is the Kryptonite to biased reporting, the bane of outright lies.
Matt Pearl owns and operates The Tri-County Ledger.
