Skip to content

Mather takes Townie tradition into Hall of Fame

FORUM FILE
Northwest Missouri State defenders Caleb Mather and Ben Althoff swallow up the Fort Hays running back for a no gain in the second quarter on Nov. 4, 2017, in Bearcat Stadium.

MARYVILLE, Mo. — “It is every little kid’s dream to play for the Spoofhounds and the Bearcats,” Caleb Mather said. “In Maryville, you are a Spoofhound on Friday night and then you are a Bearcat on Saturday afternoon. Being able to grow up and actually live that dream and walk on that field, it is just special, very special.”

The 2013 Spoofhound graduate grew up in Title Town where football reigns supreme and his knew his dream wasn’t unique, and that made living it even more exhilarating.

“Myles Burnsides, that was always the one that really stands out as a Townie who went on and did really great things at Northwest,” Mather said. “… Seeing him throw up the ‘Townie T,’ he was MIAA Defensive Player of the Year my freshman year of high school, so just seeing that gives you the goal of what can happen for a kid from Maryville. And then being able to step out there, make a big play and throw it up — that was just a dream come true.”

Mather was simply a winner during his time playing football in Maryville. As a Spoofhound, he was a part of two state champion football teams and won an individual shot put state title in track and field. As a Bearcat, Mather was a part of three national championship football teams.

All that winning has culminated in Mather being selected to the Spoofhound Athletics Hall of Fame, joining Bill Tobin in the Induction Class of 2025 as the first primarily-football inductees. The rest of the Class of 2025 includes Jordan Stiens, Joe Drake and the 1982 state champion football team.

“That was a really cool feeling,” Mather said. “Just growing up in Maryville, always being in Maryville and looking up to all those people who came before us and our class — it was really cool just thinking of all the people who laid the foundation before and having the honor of being recognized.”

Like many kids growing up in Maryville, football was Mather’s favorite sport from the beginning.

“It all started with my family — watching football, loving football, always wanting to be a football player, want to be like my dad who was a good football player,” Mather said. “Just always being around the sport was really the start of it. Then whenever you go to school, you see the older kids in elementary school wearing their jerseys to school and that is the point where it is like, ‘oh wow, I really want to do this.’ Then you get be be on the team and it’s like, ‘oh my gosh, I have a real football helmet on, real pads, and I get to actually hit somebody.’ That was real fun.”

Mather eventually got to that age where he could begin playing football with his friends, but the family aspect of football remained with his father coaching him. Mather gets emotional talking about how special that experience was.

“My dad (Jeff Mather) coached the football team along with the other dads,” Mather said through his own emotion. “Having that opportunity to spend all that time with him was just extremely valuable — learning the value of hard work and doing your best even when it is hard. Those are the life lessons that I take away from sports.”

The family aspect continued all the way until he was in high school with his future-wife’s father running the Spoofhound defense and working with the young freshman defensive lineman who got the opportunity to play and travel with the varsity.

“My wife, Baylee (Scarbrough), her dad was on the staff my freshman year,” Mather said. “He was our defensive coordinator and I got to play for him. That is a cool opportunity. I don’t feel like a whole lot of people are coached by their father-in-law, so that was an awesome opportunity.”

Making all the trips with the team and learning from the veterans on that 2009 team is something that Mather says helped shape the rest of his football career.

“That was a whirlwind of an experience,” Mather said. “Just being that young guy and looking to those people that came before and realizing how they set up the culture, set up the attitude, the way that we work and all that stuff. … Freshman year, that was just an incredible opportunity.”

Maryville had 1-score wins over Lawson and Hogan Prep through the state tournament, but by the time the Hounds made it to the final, they were rolling.

In the state championship game at St. Louis’ Edward Jones Dome, the home of the St. Lotus Rams at the time, Maryville rolled to a 35-0 win over Brentwood.

“Playing in the dome where the pros play, that was really cool,” Mather said.

Mather’s sophomore and junior seasons ended short of the state title game, but that drove the Spoofhounds going into Mather’s senior season.

“Starting as little third graders, we always wanted to win that state championship and go out on top,” Mather said. “When that year finally got there, it is like, ‘oh wow, this is it.’

“Senior year, obviously that is the year that everyone is focused on. You want to go out on top. You want to have the best year that you can.”

The 2012 Spoofhounds were dominant all season long with their only close game coming in the finale with a 27-20 win at Lafayette. None of the playoff games were within 20 points either as Maryville crushed Center 49-26 in the semifinals.

That set up an undefeated showdown with John Burroughs in the Class 3 state championship. John Burroughs was led by future NFL All-Pro running back Ezekiel Elliott.

“Whenever we stepped on the field, that is when you could really tell — this kid is really special,” Mather said.

Elliott played a great game with 18 carries for 218 yards and two touchdowns, adding 5 catches for 72 yards and an 84-yard kickoff return for a touchdown, but the Spoofhounds earned the 35-22 win with senior quarterback Jonathan Baker running in the game-sealing touchdown with 37 seconds left.

“As a defensive line, we didn’t really think too much about him being the best in the state and going on to Ohio State, be a Heisman frontrunner, win a national championship, go on and play for the Cowboys, and have a 10-year career in the NFL,” Mather said. “That really wasn’t on our minds then. That is the cool part. That is the story we get to tell after.”

Mather finished that season as the Class 3 Defensive Player of the Year. He was a 2-time All-State First Teamer. He was joined on the all-state teams by classmates Baker, Derek Stiens and Eric Sigman — as well as underclassmen Brody McMahon, Trent Nally and Jackson Morrison.

“Having the opportunity to play with your guys, that’s just special,” Mather said of his senior class.

While football was always the No. 1 sport for Mather, he discovered track and field as he got older and that sport quickly became another favorite for him.

“I started playing football in third grade,” Mather said. “So that was my favorite sport, hands down favorite sport, until track came along in middle school. … That became a big part as well, but I would say that football was still definitely No. 1 and track was definitely a really close second.”

Just like in football, Mather had role models in the community that he looked up to and one of those was the school record-holder in the shot put and discus at the time — Ben McKim.

“Ben McKim was so instrumental in pouring a whole bunch of time into all of our lives,” Mather said. “He just meant a lot to me. … He spent a lot of time with us when we were all little. He was not too cool for us and that was something that I’ll never forget.”

Mather learned to embrace the team aspect of track and field while keeping his competitive side. He would end up breaking McKim’s shot put and discus records, and winning the state title in the shot put as a junior and finishing as the runner-up as a senior. He also earned a fifth-place state medal in the discus.

“Track was always the fun season,” Mather said. “You come out of football season, everything is super intense, you know exactly what you are going to be doing every day, you go through that process. … In general, track season was a little more laid back so it was a time where you could just have a little bit more fun. Obviously you still want to do your best and are always pushing to do your best, but you could relax a little bit. That was what was fun about track season.”

After his playing career at Northwest, Mather and his wife Baylee moved to Tulsa, Oklahoma, where Mather was able to coach football and track and field.

“My wife Baylee (Scarbrough) is six months pregnant, so we are super excited to have our first baby boy in March,” Mather said. “We are high school sweethearts. Baylee is a Townie also. She went on to play softball at Northwest. We got married while we were in college. … We started teaching at a private christian school in Tulsa, Oklahoma.”

Mather has stepped away from coach as he’s become an Assistant Principal at Lincoln Christian School in Tulsa. But the Spoofhound always had the ability to stun his players and students.

“Down in Oklahoma, a lot of the kids are Dallas Cowboys fans, so that is a fun one — ‘Oh yeah, I played against Ezekiel Elliott,’” Mather said.

Mather’s main message to the next generation is simpler than having to meet an All-Pro running back at the line of scrimmage.

“That’s what I always tell my students and my athletes now,” Mather said. “Remember that this time is going to end and these opportunities aren’t going to last forever, so enjoy every second of being able to spend time with your teammates. That is really what is the fun part. That is the stuff that you remember.”

Leave a Comment