William Coy’s to permanently close after Saturday

William Coy’s logo
MARYVILLE, Mo. — William Coy’s Farm to Table Restaurant will close for good after dinner on Saturday, according to a post on the restaurant’s Facebook page.
The post from the restaurant said it had been “an honor to serve the Maryville community for these past 6 years,” and that the restaurant will remain open until 10 p.m. Saturday.
Shortly after the restaurant made the announcement late Wednesday afternoon, the city of Maryville announced that the two sides “mutually agreed” not to renew the restaurant company’s lease at the Mozingo Event Center at Mozingo Lake Recreation Park. William Coy’s had been the only third-party restaurant at Mozingo since it opened in 2018 at the then-new event center.
“We deeply appreciate the dedication and service of William Coy’s throughout their time at Mozingo,” said City Manager Greg McDanel in a statement. “Their team has been an integral part of enhancing the experience for visitors to Mozingo Lake Recreation Park, and we wish them the very best in their future endeavors.”
The city plans to seek a new restaurant partner for the event center, the news release stated.
Brown Bread, the company that owns and operates William Coy’s, signed an initial lease with the city in 2018 and began operating in September of that year. The lease was for $2,500 per month and included some other provisions, including that the restaurant would be subject to city sales taxes even though it is outside of city limits. The original owner of Brown Bread, Michael Foust, who owned another farm-to-table restaurant in Kansas City, left the company in 2019 and William Coy’s head chef, Mitchell Cosbey, has owned the company and the restaurant since.
“William Coy’s has been proud to call Mozingo home and serve this wonderful community,” Cosbey said in the news release. “While this chapter is coming to a close, we are excited about new opportunities and look forward to seeing the continued success of Mozingo Lake Recreation Park.”
The initial lease term ended in 2022 and the two sides signed a new agreement at the same rate of rent in addition to another $12,500 to address a “rent discrepancy associated with” Foust, city documents stated at the time of the lease agreement.
The lease also had the potential for a much longer term: The contract included three five-year options, the first of which could have triggered next year. Triggering the option would have continued the lease for five years at the same terms instead of seeing it expire at the end of March 2025, according to city documents.
