Forum Editorial: North Nodaway’s phone ban is the right decision

EDITORIAL MUG: Editorial art Vertical
The internet was supposed to be a global information superhighway that brought us all closer together, removed barriers to communication and fostered understanding among us all.
While it has certainly done all those things to some degree, we have not found a way to control the firehose, and so many of us across the world find ourselves drowning in the rush of social media, misinformation and unlimited capacity for desensitization that access to everyone, everything, everywhere, all the time, has forced upon us.
Nowhere is that more noticeable than in today’s children, who have never known a world without broadband and WiFi, and have been plugged in practically since birth (wirelessly, of course).
Actually, it’s definitely noticeable in all of us, isn’t it? Not just kids. Regardless of age, all of us find ourselves tethered to our phones in ways that oscillate along a spectrum of useful, comical, disturbing and sad, don’t we?
But maybe we think of social media and smartphones as an anchor particularly weighing down our kids because we know already how instant access to everything and everyone can be both so daunting, exhilarating and enlightening all at the same time. And we know that for kids, everything is just 10 times more. More intense, more exciting, more hurtful — more everything.
As a society, we’ve largely decided to do nothing about this, focusing instead on whatever topics we’re so frequently told are urgent and apocalyptic and require our utmost outrage or celebration immediately. Because that’s what we see on social media, of course. On our phones.
All of that is a very long-winded way of saying that we applaud the North Nodaway school district for becoming the first in our county to implement a student phone ban while in school.
In an ideal world, having constant access to the information superhighway in their pockets all day would be a boon to education, and a way for all students to easily connect with people and perspectives they would have never otherwise ever known.
In a more realistic but still unreachable world, we would put an emphasis on teaching our kids (and adults) how to safely and responsibly wade into a world where the vast majority of information and people cannot be trusted. And we would help our kids, as they form their lifelong worldviews in the process of becoming who they will be, stay rooted in the reality and values that we wish we could exemplify a little more.
Instead, we are left with the world we live in, where amid a torrent of TikToks, devastating Instagram clapbacks and an unending stream of distractions, we charge some underpaid, underappreciated and undersupported professionals with teaching our kids how to do algebra and why Shakespeare is lit.
If it’s between a teacher and a phone, the teacher doesn’t stand a chance.
Although we wish there were a better solution, North Nodaway’s decision to separate kids from their phones while in class is the best one remaining in an imperfect situation. It will not prepare them for a world full of phones that awaits outside. But it will allow them to at least turn more of a focus toward developing the basic tools and skills that they will need, and will hopefully allow school to be a place of relative emotional stability where bullying and all the cruelties that come with being a kid are a little less magnified. Even just a little.
We understand that some parents have concerns about how they and their children will adjust or how any of a million specific and unlikely scenarios should warrant an exception.
But, unfortunately, there’s no way to keep adults off their phones.
Maybe it’s not too late for everybody else.
