Pearls: A little hard work and dirty hands won’t hurt kids

EDITORIAL MUG: Matt Pearl
My children asked me a question that I was expecting from them—I wasn’t sure when, or how old they would get before I heard it—and I had to offer them a fatherly response to it:
‘If Labor Day is supposed to be a work holiday, why are we doing yard work?’
And it’s a fair question. My wife and I gave them the shortened, probably half-true version of the holiday’s history—about how the industrial age changed the labor patterns of Americans, and how Labor Day broke up the grueling cycle of work for many folks who weren’t receiving much time away from the factories.
My kids, like most American kids for several generations now, have not known the toils that our predecessors endured in building the nation’s industries. I consider it a good thing that we don’t have preteens working 18-hour days at the mill anymore.
So for most of us, Labor Day has changed. In retail, it’s a chance for many people to work during a holiday when the other half of the population has the day off—fast food joints probably make a killing on September’s first Monday.
For my children, it’s that built-in single-day break from school that they’d been anticipating since their return to classes.
Before I continue, I will say that I try not to bore my children endlessly with lectures about how easy their lives are, how blessed we are in this modern age, how thankful we should be to the generations passed, etc. But I do bore them occasionally with these types of talks.
Giving a little attention to the lawn and the garden on Labor Day—a day that my kids believe (or believed) to be a deserved day off—is not my being a grumpy parent. And to be fair to them, the kids really didn’t fuss. They weren’t what we would typically call motivated to hustle and get as much done as possible, but they cooperated and accomplished a few things.
It’s tough as a parent to know how much freedom to give kids. Part of you understands, remembering how it felt to go to school, and how great it was when you got a day away from it. The playful side of me wants to just turn them loose with the TV and the video games and the snack food and let them enjoy the day their way.
But there’s another part of me, an ever-strengthening core, that insists that I use moments like Labor Day 2024 to instill something more important than MarioKart or binging Netflix. I want my kids to learn to use their free time constructively, not just freely.
My kiddos can drag tree limbs to the burn pile. They can pull weeds. They can pick apples. We didn’t sacrifice all of our fun for work’s sake by any means: we grilled up a good lunch, they played hide-and-seek and we ordered pizza for dinner.
But they also got their hands dirty and their brows sweaty. I’m hoping to show them that a ‘good day’ is not a day without labor, but one where we get to choose our labors, or at least to participate in activities and work that enlivens us.
The problem of balancing the responsibilities of the home with the availability of entertainment and leisure is one that isn’t going away anytime soon. Kids can have more fun goofing off than they ever could in history. And mine get to do their fair share.
It’s important, though, for us to put them behind wheelbarrows, to hand them rakes and shovels and to have them do the kinds of jobs that demand a pair of work gloves. Labor Day in the 21st century is a far cry from 1882, when it began to be celebrated here stateside in New York. A little yard work celebrates the work our ancestors performed a century ago, and that slice of pizza lets us appreciate our modern privileges. Win-win.
Matt Pearl owns and operates The Tri-County Ledger.
