Skip to content

Pearls: Weighing in on standardized testing in schools

EDITORIAL MUG: Matt Pearl

The state testing window for public school kids is officially open for many of our area students. Every yer I have been in education, the Missouri Assessment Program (MAP) has occupied at least a little space in the great narrative of our school systems. So I guess I have a few thoughts.

I try to keep one foot planted in each of my professional ‘worlds.’ As a career educator, I owe it to all of my students, their parents, my teachers, the district patrons and any other stakeholders to impress the importance of kids learning by high standards and performing their best on standardized tests.

My other ‘world’ is that of a journalist, the private sector, where I know certain of my readers are looking critically at test scores and sizing up their local schools, while others scratch their heads about why anyone would make such a big commotion about a set of standardized tests in the first place.

And it’s true that if you view MAP and End-of-Course (EOC) testing in Missouri as a goal – that is, you believe that districts are aiming to achieve high numbers on tests as ‘the finish line’ – then I can see why people are so critical regarding the importance placed on the MAP program.

But if instead you view the tests as the natural consequences of what is (or is not) being learned in classrooms, then you have a different vantage point. You begin instead to see learning as the goal and the test as the meter stick.

There’s another wrinkle to this problem, and it has to do with population size. I am an administrator for one of the smaller districts in the area – around 10-12 kids per class on average. Folks who work with statistics will tell you that a dozen test takers is a very small sample size, meaning that the quality of the instruction and the quality of the test itself are each difficult to judge, because you only have a handful of students giving you data.

That means that one year, a small class that has received a healthy amount of individualized instruction per member might put your test scores through the roof, and then the next year a class with perhaps different abilities or with different personal dynamics might look like your educational quality as a school is plummeting.

I’ll leave that point as it is, but it bears remembering for all you readers who send your kids to small schools: the stats will never be fair or accurate compared with larger districts. If your scores stay consistently high, then your school culture is positive and winning. If the scores stay consistently low – like a decade – then you might have some problems to solve.

When I was still in the classroom (I have to laugh; it was just a year ago), my philosophy was somewhat relaxed. I learned early in my career that when I get uptight about testing – or anything, for that matter – my class would get anxious right along with me.

I would change the narrative: ‘We have test writers who are trying to prove you don’t know the things you’re supposed to know. Let’s relax, take a good test, and prove them wrong.’ That was my message for years, and most of those years, it worked fairly well.

If parents asked me what they needed to do to prepare their kids for testing (and they rarely did ask), I had a few tips I gave them. I told them to talk to their kids about the tests llike they were important, but not experiences worth getting stressed about taking. Get them breakfast, and put them to bed the night before.

Standardized tests are like track meets: there’s a whole field of competitors out there, but when you’re in your lane, you’re only ever competing against one person – yourself. And perhaps that, my friends, is the single greatest lifelong lessons contained in the MAP/EOC tests.

Matt Pearl owns and operates The Tri-County Ledger.

Leave a Comment