Skip to content

Forum Editorial: Senate’s legislation on initiative petition is shameful

EDITORIAL MUG: Editorial art Vertical

When learning about our nation and its founding principles, it’s nearly impossible for any grade school student to escape a civics class without hearing a quote commonly attributed to Voltaire:

“I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.”

If we were forced to boil our national creed down to one sentence, we believe that’s as good a sentence as any to sum up what we’re all about here in the United States.

Generation after generation, we are a nation that values our principles and, at our most aspirational, does not seek to silence voices we disagree with. Instead, we champion them.

Most of our state senators must have been absent that day of civics class.

Last week, Senate Republicans followed through on their only major policy goal they can agree on, passing legislation that, if approved by voters, would make it significantly more difficult to change the state constitution via initiative petition.

Instead of a simple majority, the measure would require a majority vote in five of Missouri’s eight congressional districts in order to pass — called a “concurrent majority.”

Some, including our own senator, Rusty Black, say that this legislation is about ensuring we in rural Missouri “have a voice.” Not only that, it ensures our voice is so loud that no one else’s really matters.

According to The Missouri Independent, that means that less than a quarter of Missouri residents could torpedo any amendment that was put on the ballot by initiative petition. Maybe we should feel special, because under this plan, our votes would count two-to-three times more than our counterparts’ a hundred miles or so to the south.

Well, at least when there’s a constitutional amendment on the ballot that came from “we, the people.”

In Missouri, there are three ways to get a constitutional amendment on the ballot: by initiative petition, by constitutional convention or by an act of the General Assembly. The Senate’s legislation would only make two of those ways adhere to the concurrent majority threshold.

Guess which one would still require only a majority vote?

Yes, that’s right, if the legislature decides to put an amendment on the ballot — like the one approved by the Senate last week — well, then the old simple majority standard is just fine.

But if it comes from us? Legislators don’t trust us to make the right decision. What happened to this being about our voice…?

This mentality is rampant not just in Missouri, but across our country, where discourse has regressed into suspicious tribalism instead of impassioned disagreement. There is no longer much interest in debate, or discussion, or compromise, or finding a middle ground. The only goal is to silence other opinions in any way possible so that there is no risk that someone might actually find some common ground.

So having different standards based on where the proposal came from? No problem. If that’s what it takes.

But is that what we should want to stand for here in Missouri?

Our legislators say yes, because ultimately, it’s not about our voice at all. No one can seriously pretend that it is about anything except ensuring abortion remains illegal in Missouri. Senate Republicans believe that this one issue is so important that it overrides our most American of principles: that we are a nation founded on disagreement, compromise, and the belief that no one’s voice should be the only one allowed to speak.

Whether we agree with the senators’ opinion on abortion — as some of us do — is beside the point. The very foundation of our country, and every state in it, is that how we make our shared laws matters.

We can twist ourselves into knots trying to justify this break from our principles, defending it by saying we are serving a greater moral good that does not bow to opinion, majority or otherwise.

But we reject the lie that it is impossible to live in Missouri in 2024 as a person of both principle and morality. And we are ashamed that our legislators have proven eager to abandon basic democratic principles under the guise of moral conviction. To pretend they are mutually exclusive is an insult to both, and results in staying true to neither.

We believe Missouri is capable of being home to people who deeply disagree over important issues. That’s what democratic government is all about. We should not be so afraid of disagreement that we seek to keep any who disagree with us out of the process entirely. That’s true whether it’s a minority who hold a different view, or, as the legislature believes in this case, a majority.

If we no longer believe that Missouri is a place where the only way to impose your views on others is to convince them, then we will have abandoned what it ought to mean to be American.

We encourage our representatives in the House, Jeff Farnan and Mazzie Christensen, to soundly reject this proposal and any other proposal that compromises our most basic democratic principles and that are to be selectively applied based on who is likely to agree with us.

We would say it’s something that would have had Voltaire rolling over in his grave, but in reality, Voltaire never actually said his famous phrase.

The words were written by Evelyn Beatrice Hall in an anecdotal biography of Voltaire in 1906, which she published under a pen name — still another layer removed from Voltaire. But she believed the phrase helped to capture the essence of Voltaire’s convictions on free speech, and a century later, it’s the content of the message that endures — not where it came from.

If Ms. Hall were writing today, she might have come up with something different, but just as appropriate, for subsequent generations to remember about what our Missouri legislature is saying:

“We disapprove of what you say. So shut up.”

Leave a Comment