Skip to content

Pearls: Sorry, no refunds on your privacy

EDITORIAL MUG: Matt Pearl

The biggest question I have posed over the past few years on the subject of technology is this: Will the pendulum swing?

By that, I mean, will technology go so far—too far, perhaps—and the human response will be to push back against it?

If so, we might be arriving at a breaking point with artificial intelligence (A.I.). For folks who make their living online—writing content for websites, for example—A.I. is being touted as a powerful, impressive tool that will revolutionize the industry.

Not unlike how the internet was sold to us 25 years ago, if you’ll recall. As a newspaper publisher, I can tell you for a certainty that the World Wide Web has done precious little to improve the plight of community journalism. Unless you consider half-truths and public feuds on Facebook as quality local reporting.

It’s no outrageous claim for me to predict that A.I. has the potential to automate thought itself. In fact, it is already doing this for you. The ads you see on social media, for example, which in large part now target your specific habits of shopping and patterns of thought.

For the first time since the age of the internet swept all of us off our feet, I have more lately begun to consider removing as much of myself from it as I can. It has become more and more apparent over the past few years that the structures that run everything from search engines to social media to online retailing are benefitting greatly from knowing as much as they can about what I do, what I like, what I buy and how I think.

Add A.I. to that mix, and something incredible happens. By voluntarily putting my life online and giving enough clues to the vastness of cyberspace, I have aided and abetted the barons of digital media in creating a digital fingerprint of me.

Social media knows what I want to buy before I have the sense to search for it online myself. It’s like playing a game of Clue against a digital monstrosity that knows what I know—and what every other player in the game knows. The Web doesn’t need to see the envelope with the hidden cards—Mr. Green with the lead pipe in the conservatory—to know the answer to the mystery. You and I told it everything it needs to know.

And I don’t like it.

I am predictable in many ways, I’m sure. My wife can buy gifts for me that I enjoy, because she knows me—my quirks, my interests and my sense of humor—and can assemble the necessary information to surprise me with something I didn’t even know that I wanted or needed.

A mechanism of artificial intelligence shouldn’t be able to know me in such a private way. But it does. Every time I searched, clicked a link or bought something, I dropped the internet a hint about me—and the Web never forgot what I told it. Every hyperlink told a grotesque, digital Santa Claus what I wanted for Christmas, and now a set of servers here and another room full of computers there—the robotic, remorseless, amoral gatekeepers of our information—know all about me.

And it’s really the reason I haven’t shut down my online usage completely. What’s the use now? A digital version of me—my capitalist preferences, my spending habits, my tastes in everything from politics to fast food—will roam cyberspace from now on.

I hope it was all worth it. I hope we know what we have done. Brick and mortar businesses are suffering and dying, but Amazon is just fine. They know when you’re about to run out of razor blades and underarm deodorant, and they send you a reminder to buy them. Like all aspects of online media, it at first feels good to be remembered and to have a retailer catering to your specific needs.

That is, until that retailer knows too much and one of your most valuable possessions, your privacy, is gone. Sorry folks: no refunds or returns on that one.

Matt Pearl owns and operates The Tri-County Ledger.

Leave a Comment