Skip to content

Pearls: Come on, that can’t happen

EDITORIAL MUG: Matt Pearl

Did you ever find yourself critiquing the logic of something that was never meant to be logical in the first place? Let me explain what I mean.

It has already been a rich season of Christmas movie watching at the Pearl home. Every single holiday movie – even the Hallmark variety, which I this far have successfully avoided – depends to some degree upon the suspension of disbelief: you and I have to accept fantastic, magic things as truth, or we can’t really enjoy the movie.

When I was a kid, I completed this task flawlessly. Presents were delivered via chimney, reindeer never woke anyone from their sleep, the Grinch could lift a sleigh filled with all things Christmas clean over his head and it always magically snows on Christmas Eve.

But now I’m well, older. I enjoy the magic and fantasy of the movies, but for some reason I find myself getting caught up in the details of the stories themselves. And the more possible the movie, the worse I get.

Take what is probably my favorite Christmas movie, Home Alone, for example. For anyone who hasn’t seen the film, the following paragraphs contain spoilers.

Also, how have you not seen it? Anyway…

What kind of criminal intruders would take that much abuse? Who would stay for 20 minutes – maybe more – in a house that was booby-trapped like that? I’d be back in that van and heading up the road after I grabbed that red-hot doorknob, I can tell you that.

See, this is what I mean. I’m willing to concede that in the imaginary world of Kevin McAllister’s home defense that it is possible for a middle elementary schooler to design and execute a flawless set of pain-inducing traps, all for the purpose of turning away a pair of burglars who – however blundering they might be – have successfully robbed numerous homes. But I can’t accept the fact that the burglars persist through the pain and keep trying to rob the house.

I was watching The Santa Clause with my wife and kids here a week or two ago. In a transitional moment of the story, the protagonist Scott Calvin (aka Santa Claus) begins his white-haired, beard-growing, weight-gaining journey toward becoming the boss at the North Pole.

As I watched that one, I had no issue with a man becoming Santa through a legal loophole that requires him to replace the previous Santa, who falls to his untimely end from a roof. My problem was more basic:

‘There’s no way anyone could really gain weight and grow a beard that fast,’ I heard myself say during the movie. Later on, I thought more on the subject: ‘Really, Matt?’ I asked myself, ‘You’re having trouble with the beard growth and weight gain? That’s the unbelievable part?’ My 10-year-old self would be so ashamed of me.

Now somehow, when I watch the Christmas specials that were made in the 60s and 70s, the ones that featured either animation or puppets shot in the stop-motion, I get along much better. Rudolph can fly, and his nose can glow – I have no issue with it. Frosty can come to life at the proper placement of a top hat. Santa Claus can come to town and face opposition from city government through clever use of chimneys and stockings. These all add up.

But when Buddy the Elf makes his way to New York, it somehow bothers me that he walked to the Big Apple from his childhood home at the North Pole.

I take all of this as a sign, but which interpretation I should apply is still up in the air.

Perhaps it means that I have a finely tuned mind, one that carefully considers the implications of movies, even the fantasy variety of them. Maybe…

…Or perhaps I should cool it on the Christmas movies for a while.

Matt Pearl owns and operates The Tri-County Ledger.

Leave a Comment