A Word from Woehlk: Shining a light on a glaring issue

Skye Pournazari
A Word from Woehlk: Shining a light on a glaring issue
While I was driving in the rain one night recently, I couldn’t help but think of a joke that’s really big with the cervid population these days: two deer are taking their time crossing the road one night when suddenly they’re bathed in light from something cresting the hill in front of them. One of the deer immediately sprints off the side of the road, getting out of the way and waiting in the grass for his companion. But the other deer stays where he is, peering intently at the oncoming pair of lights that are getting brighter and brighter. Finally, as the roar of the engine becomes unmistakable, the deer hops to the side of the road, joining his friend in safety just before the car zooms past.
“Geez, what were you just standing there for?? It almost hit you!” the first deer says.
The other deer responds, “Well those lights were so bright, I couldn’t tell if there was a car behind them!”
… OK, well, deer aren’t known for their sense of humor. But, as with most stories that deer tell, the joke contains a nugget of truth: headlights sure do seem like they’re awfully bright these days, no?
I’m sure all of us have had a similar experience with what seem to be particularly glaring, white or even bluish headlights from vehicles in the oncoming lane or behind us, lighting up everything as if they have an ultra-high-beam setting that’s reserved just for you.
Most likely, these vehicles, which are indeed becoming more and more common as they become standard, are outfitted with LED headlights that have a less orangish glow than the halogen lights that were more commonly used over the past couple of decades.
LEDs have a lot of advantages, chief among them being that they’re more efficient for your car, and their more neutral hue makes it easier for you to see.
Well, as long as you’re in the car with the LEDs anyway.
Headlights are subject to brightness regulations and are tested by carmakers and safety agencies. Typically, they measure headlight brightness in “lumens.”
However, one drawback of the method, apparently, is that, according to oft-cited expert Mark Rea, professor at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai in New York, lumens aren’t a terribly helpful measurement for this purpose because human eyes are more sensitive to higher wavelength red light than to lower wavelength blue light, he told Slate last year in a piece about this very issue.
What that means is, even though a whiter LED light and a more orange halogen light might measure the same number of lumens, the LED light could actually look up to 40 percent brighter, he said.
I’d say you can test this out at home with that lumen meter everyone has stashed away in a kitchen drawer, but it’s probably even easier just to drive around to see if it passes the sniff test. It’s not your imagination, or, for once, even my imagination: headlights are indeed brighter than they used to be as LED lights become standard on more and more vehicles.
OK terrific! Time to do something about it!
Or so I thought.
Unfortunately for my column’s purposes, I don’t even get the chance to make an impassioned plea for lawmakers to please step in and protect us from swerving around the afterimages of cars gone by: included in the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law in 2021 was a solution that makes this problem a moot point.
Starting in that year, U.S. regulators started allowing a new technology that car manufacturers had introduced in Europe about a decade ago: adaptive driving beams.
Prior to 2021, the U.S. had only allowed two settings on headlights: high beams and low beams. Adaptive beams, though, use sensors on the exterior of the vehicle to detect where your light is shining, and what kinds of things it’s about to shine on. Then, the computer that is your car these days calculates what’s likely to be another car, and shuts off the emitters that are lighting up that section in front of you. The effect is that a shadow appears in your beam and follows, say, an oncoming car, so that your light is shining everywhere except on the other car.
Now, I didn’t think I could sound much more like a crotchety old man than writing a column about how headlights are too damn bright these days, but here goes: Mark me down as “skeptical” that this technology is really going to work properly all the time. Right?
On the other hand, automakers have been testing the technology on Europeans — err, Europeans have been using it — for several years now, and safety organizations agree that they’ve seen a dip in nighttime crashes on vehicles with this technology equipped.
So OK, I guess we’ve only got another decade or so of the glaring headlights until the new adaptive beams become the standard.
Really, then, did you need to know anything in this column after all?
I guess not. But at least you’ll have something to talk about with the next deer you run into.
Geoffrey Woehlk is the news editor at The Forum.
