Skip to content

Pearls: Both major parties are to blame

Matt Pearl

On Monday morning, I watched my almost-two-year-old put her shoes on the wrong feet for the 100th time this week.

I have at times asked myself whether the laws of mathematics and averages have finally broken down at the cosmic level: how can a person not accidently occasionally put her shoes on the right feet?

And when they’re on, why doesn’t it bother her that her left foot is hitting the wrong part of the shoe, because it has been awkwardly fit up on her right? I guess being oblivious to such things is one of the privileges of toddlerhood.

A few days earlier, prior to the Monday shoe mix-up, I was discussing politics with a friend who said he always voted a straight ticket in favor of his preferred party and had done so for many years. I had to shake my head.

‘But what about when parties change their views on something?’ I asked him.

‘I’ve been a registered ******* for years now,’ he responded. ‘I believe in something called loyalty.’

Well, I guess he had me there. In my voting habits, I have tended to be less loyal to any party than I have been toward ideas and people. In fact, my solution–my having never run for office and never intending to do so–has been not to register as a member of any party. That way, when I vote for a person I believe in, I don’t have the inconvenience of letting his or her party affiliation potentially distract my voting intentions.

An individual a couple of years ago told me to my face that I was a Republican, and my writing said it all. For what it’s worth, several of my registered Republican friends think I’m too moderate. My self-analysis: I couldn’t care less about any of those things.

In my life, I have voted for presidential candidates from both major parties. On the local level, I would really love someone to explain to me why it matters which party our elected courthouse officials support. When you die, does it matter that the coroner was a Republican? Does the collector/treasurer do math differently because she’s a Democrat? Those are absurd questions, and each of us knows better.

But our political focus as a nation has shifted sharply away from local-level politics and policies–which have a pretty profound effect upon our taxes, our laws and our way of life–and toward the national stage. It’s not unusual for a small town to struggle to find anyone to run for mayor or the city council, but everybody has a Facebook opinion on President Trump or Speaker Pelosi.

My point: when we stubbornly subscribe to a single political ideology, aren’t we likely to end up like that toddler, walking around with shoes on the wrong feet and pretending to be content?

You get to an election cycle and the party you have long supported is leaving you behind: what do you do? You have two choices: either you vote for the other choice, or you become more entrenched in the party’s view of the world, all at the expense of your current views–and possibly your integrity.

We treat presidential elections like they’re the end all and be all. I like low taxes but am not thrilled with a 14-digit (yes, 14-digit) national debt. When we cut taxes and keep spending the same amount of money–and I’m no economist, for certain–it seems like that debt will get worse and worse. Who did that? Democrats or Republicans?

The answer: change the or to and. It was the whole bunch of them.

So how long are folks like you and me going to line up with the major parties? The answer: until another party has some hope of winning, which doesn’t appear to be in the cards anytime soon.

Matt Pearl owns and operates newspapers in King City, Albany and Grant City.

Leave a Comment