Skip to content

Pearls: An order to use a little common sense

Matt Pearl

I read a post online the other day where an individual was praising Governor Mike Parson for enacting the “Stay Home, Missouri’ order ( I added the comma, because it needs one…). I myself have no objection to the measure, but at the point it took effect – 12:01 a.m. Monday morning – practically every county and many municipalities in the state had already ruled on the matter.

Now I understand that a state regulation carries weight that local ordinances cannot equal, and I do think it’s important that Gov. Parson put the order into effect. But if this COVID-19 situation has taught me anything, it’s that political posturing becomes the star of the show, particularly in an election year.

It’s a trap into which we all may fall: caring more about how our actions are seen than we do about doing what is right. I myself have at times sat at my desk, wondering at length how I will be perceived based upon a decision I make. All too often, the direction of public perception and individual morality find themselves running in opposing directions.

The governor stated his reasons for enacting the Stay at Home measure before putting the order into effect. When I watched his brief press conference, I noted that the first several minutes of his remarks pertained to his thought process; the order itself came late in his monologue. That’s not purely a criticism: the expectation everyone seems to hold these days is that everybody explains every decision to everyone else all the time.

We’re like the child who asks a parent ‘Why?’ I grew up in a home where the parents never felt any particular need to answer that question. It’s different with the governor and the state’s citizens: to the letter of the law, we are actually the ‘parents’ in that relationship, and he is the duty bound ‘son’ of Missourians. But how often does it really feel like that?

Folks were calling for Parson to order citizens to stay home for days – weeks before he did it. And I understand their point: a governor’s order carries with it a level of seriousness: when the state’s chief executive puts such a measure into effect, it is a sign to citizens of the seriousness of a situation. It would have been beneficial to his cause to have given the order considerably earlier.

And the other part of me wants to ask, ‘Why did everyone need a state order to use a little common sense?’ I mean, the counties around had already given just about the same order. We all have information at our fingertips that implored us to stay home. Were we really so obtuse that we needed Mike Parson to tell us coronavirus was dangerous?

That’s why in my mind I’m a conservative: I’d like to think that people can come to the right decision without never-ending legislative actions and executive orders. But in practice, I become more liberal: people make a lot of bad decisions, and who’s going to protect the folks who are behaving from the folks who are misbehaving?

I have read from several news agencies that it appears America may have just gone past the peak of its COVID-19 outbreak, and that the coming weeks show better promise than originally forecast. I hope it’s true. When schools began to close a few weeks ago, I made one prediction to my wife:

‘If this works and we slow down the spread of the disease, everyone is going to say we overreacted, and that coronavirus really wasn’t that bad.’ And that’s what is about to happen. Fewer people (we pray) will die than originally predicted, and a large portion of our population will say, ‘See! Why did we wreck our economy over this? It was nothing!’ Fortunately, we’ll never truly know the result that might have followed if we had done nothing and carried on with life as usual. I know what I suspect: far greater infection rates and therefore far greater fatality rates. Perhaps we have erred, but hopefully we have done so on the side of caution. No economic boom can buy back lost lives, and I pray we all remember that.

Matt Pearl owns and operates newspapers in King City, Albany and Grant City.

Leave a Comment