Cobb answers survey from The Athletic

By PHIL COBB The Forum
Phil Cobb
A special thank you to Alec Lewis of The Athletic, who allowed me to use his recent survey in order to construct this week’s column.
Lewis, who is the Kansas City Royals beat writer for the popular sports coverage website, is one of my favorite follows on Twitter. I’ve been a subscriber to The Athletic since near its beginning in 2016 and the addition of Lewis to its roster of talented writers has provided interesting insight into my favorite sports team.
Recently Lewis surveyed Royals fans and on a variety of topics and when filling in my answers, I thought, “This would make a good column.”
Here we go:
1. How confident are you in the 2020 Royals?
On a scale of 1-5, I gave it a 2. Let’s be honest, although the Royals have some nice window dressing with the reconstruction of the bullpen, Salvador Perez and Adalberto Mondesi coming back healthy, new ownership, new management, etc., there are still too many question marks to pretend this team will do much more than avoid 100 losses (assuming they play at all).
The starting pitching alone is reason to doubt the success of the 2020 edition. Plus, I think this team, overall, is a little bit worse defensively.
I love Whit Merrifield, but I don’t see him in centerfield for an entire season, and unless there have been some serious behind-the-scenes developments, Hunter Dozier in right field flat out bothers me.
Yes. I definitely want Dozier in the lineup, but I saw him play right field last year and, well … yikes!
New third baseman Maikel Franco’s defense is yet to be seen in a Royals uniform, but I’ve heard everything from butcher to above average, so, that’s yet to be determined.
My only question, “Is he better than Dozier at third?”
In short, my confidence level is right around 63-99 (obviously, we don’t even know if those games will be played).
2. How confident are you the Royals are heading in the right direction over the next five years?
I gave this one a 5. I think, with new ownership, new management and a crop of young pitchers that has been called, “the best collection of young pitching I’ve ever seen” by a long-time and well-respected scout, fans should have hope.
Those things, coupled with some young position players who could develop into some of the best the team has ever seen, have me feeling good about the future.
3. How would you rate the Royals front office’s job this offseason?
That’s a tough one, but I gave it a 4. I mean, what are you supposed to do?
You’re right in the middle of an ownership change and you’re trying to put together a team for the first season under that new leadership without really having a feel for what things will be like.
Then, pow, at least the first part of the season is pulled out from under you at the last minute, when final roster spots are about to be determined.
I think the front office has done a pretty good job of keeping the ship steady through relatively rough waters.
4. How would you describe the state of the Royals?
This was a short answer question. I think, in short, what the Royals are trying to do right now is bridge the gap from a couple of really bad years to what appears to be a bright future.
Fans can go to the ballpark and cheer for familiar names and faces like Alex Gordon, Salvador Perez and Whit Merrifield, while getting a glimpse into the future with players like Adalberto Mondesi, Nicky Lopez, Dozier, etc.
But any expectations of hanging a banner this season or next are likely to result in disappointment.
5. What are your realistic expectations for the 2020 season?
This was a multiple-choice question:
• Make the playoffs
• Contend for the playoffs
• Finish above .500
• Finish below .500
• Similar winning percentage as the last two seasons
I chose finish below .500. Like I said, I think realistic progress will be avoiding 100 losses for the third-straight season.
With the team healthy and the promise of a real major league bullpen, I think they can do that.
6. Will the Royals win a World Series in the next five years?
I chose yes to this question, because I just think that if you don’t have the hope that your team will win it all within a reasonable length of time, then why are you rooting for that team?
Obviously, there’s no way to know if this will come true. I have genuine optimism that, with the bevy of young pitchers and the excitement of some of the younger position players, two to three years from now, this team will absolutely have as good a chance of winning the World Series as it did in 2014-2015.
No doubt about it, it took the stars being in perfect alignment for that to happen, but it did happen and therefore it can happen again.
7. Who will be the Royals’ next American League Most Valuable Player?
I was given the choice of Whit Merrifield, Adalberto Mondesi, Jorge Soler, Bobby Witt Jr. or none of the above. I chose Bobby Whit, Jr., because, well … I’m a dreamer.
Keep in mind that in the 50-plus year history of the franchise, the Royals have had a grand total of one AL MVP and his name is George Brett and he is in the hall of fame.
Brett batted .390, the highest average since the great Ted Williams, and led his team to the World Series to accomplish that recognition.
Needless to say, winning AL MVP awards is not really the Royals’ thing.
So, the chances of a player winning the award, even if they return to the World Series is not good.
But Witt Jr. is the latest in a long line of Kansas City prospects to be labeled as “the next George Brett” and I’m going to hold onto that promise for dear life.
8. Who is your current favorite Royals player?
This was a tough one. Alex Gordon and Salvador Perez have brought me so many great memories and so much joy, that it’s hard not to pick one of those guys. If Mike Moustakas and Lorenzo Cain were still with the team, they, too, would be neck-and-neck.
All that said, I had to pick Merrifield. I absolutely love the way he plays the game.
Every single play in the field, every at-bat, every game, every day, Merrifield performs at the highest level.
Although — and I have to think this is the fault of a flawed player development effort — Merrifield didn’t really get in on the most recent glory years, he has become the undisputed most valuable player on the team.
He never slumps and he never takes a day off.
The only reason the nickname “Two-Hit Whit” hasn’t really stuck, is that many times he gets more than two hits. Maybe he should be Multi-Hit Whit.
This column is getting too long and I still have 16 more questions to answer, so tune in next week when I’ll answer questions like, “Who is your all-time favorite Royals player” and “Which opponent do you dislike the most?”
More Information
This column is the first of a three-part series on this same topic. Check back each week for more of Phil’s answers to the survey created by Alec Lewis of The Athletic.
