Skip to content

Graves supports ‘right-to-repair’ efforts

U.S. Rep. Sam Graves R-Missouri 6th District

MARYVILLE, Mo. — During a telephone town hall with constituents Tuesday evening, Congressman Sam Graves offered unequivocal support for “right-to-repair” legislation.

“Right-to-repair” bills introduced in 20 states — including Missouri — have sought to address a problem particular to this day and age: a person’s ability to repair something they own. Until recently, repairing anything mechanical from cars, to household appliances, to telephones to tractors and combines could be done by anyone with the expertise. But as all those products have begun incorporating patented electronics that are integral to their function, the companies that sell the products have begun restricting the ability to repair them as well, allowing only licensed vendors access to the manuals and schematics, or as in the case of many John Deere products, electronic verification without which the tractor or combine won’t function.

“This new electrical stuff, Sam, John Deere and all of the tractor manufacturers don’t want to share the technology that it takes to repair all the new … high-dollar equipment,” Barry, from Hamilton, Missouri, told Graves during the town hall call.

The problem, though hardly new, has grown in scope over the past few years, resulting in efforts across the country in state legislatures to address it. In 2002, federal lawmakers pressured the auto industry into providing more information to aftermarket parts dealers and independent mechanics, but in 2012 — when Massachusetts passed a law requiring carmakers to provide the same information as they do to dealerships — car manufacturers agreed to put the policy in place nationwide to avoid having to deal with varying laws from state to state.

Since then, efforts to do the same for consumer electronics manufacturers — makers of phones, tablets, computers and similar electronic devices — and makers of agriculture equipment have picked up steam. Last year, the Federal Trade Commission held a workshop on the topic to outline the issues and discuss potential solutions, and Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren — whose state legislature introduced a bill aimed at electronics manufacturers last year — made a push for a federal “right-to-repair” law a key part of a sweeping agriculture plan during her presidential campaign.

The term “right-to-repair” is itself a slight misnomer, however. Consumers generally have the right-to-repair anything they own, but since proprietary electronic systems have become commonplace, having access to the knowledge of how to fix those things is frequently withheld. “Right-to-repair” laws would require companies to provide that information, including to third parties like independent repair shops.

Graves said he was not aware of the issue, but he fully supported any effort to ensure a farmer’s right-to-repair.

“When I started farming … I became a farm sale connoisseur, and going out and buying used equipment, because that’s all I could afford at the time,” Graves said during the town hall. “And then I would spend a lot of time … fixing it up. … And that’s the only way I could make it work, was being able to work on my own equipment and move forward.

“Now, obviously, that technology has changed considerably. I know on our combines now on the farm, obviously, they have a whole lot of electronics which are extraordinarily hard to work on. But you shouldn’t be pre-empted from working on it or doing repairs to it, so something like that would bother me in a big way if anyone was prevented from being able to work on their own equipment.”

Graves said legislation on the matter would likely need to come from the state level.

“But I would certainly weigh in and say that anyone should be able to work on their own equipment,” he said.

The Missouri Farm Bureau lists in its 2019 policy book that it supports “farmers, independent repair shops and aftermarket parts stores having access to manuals and diagnostic tools needed to repair farm equipment.” And this year, its national parent the American Farm Bureau will reportedly make the issue one of its top priorities.

Last year, right-to-repair bills introduced by St. Louis Democrat Rep. Tracy McCreery, who first proposed similar legislation in 2017, and Rep. Matt Sain, D-Kansas City, didn’t make it out of committee in Missouri. No other state with similar legislation has managed to pass one, either, frequently running into a roadblock of corporations like Microsoft, Apple, AT&T and John Deere, all of which have come out strongly against such legislation. And Graves himself, according to donation-tracking site OpenSecrets.org, has received nearly a quarter of a million dollars since his first election to Congress in 2000 from individuals and groups associated with AT&T, John Deere and the National Auto Dealers Association — another trade group strongly opposed to “right-to-repair” legislation.

This session, McCreery and Rep. Barry Hovis, R-Whitewater, have each introduced bills addressing separate issues: Hovis’ motor vehicles like combines and tractors, and McCreery’s other electronics equipment. Both bills have been referred to the Agriculture Policy Committee.

“It’s a good question, Barry, and I had not heard that John Deere was pushing that,” Graves said on the town hall call. “That’s frustrating though. I’m going to mention that the next time I talk to the John Deere representative, how frustrating something like that would be.”

Leave a Comment