A View from the Country: How Democrats can win

Richard Fulton
The New York Times had an interesting feature last Sunday which asked four knowledgeable persons to write a column around the theme of, “What do the Democrats need to do to win in 2020?”
As you might expect, each had a particular theme around which they built their argument. Let me try and outline the four themes and then you can see what you think. You don’t need to be a Democrat to play, all of us are curious about how the 2020 contest will unfold.
David Leonhard tells the Democrats to focus on corruption as a theme to undermine Trump. It is his contention that personal attacks on Trump (regardless of what you might think of his character) simply don’t hurt him, but substantive ones do. Thus, he advises the Democrats to focus on corruption — Ukraine, personal financial benefits garnered by being president, tax breaks for the rich, corrupt cabinet members.
He says to treat him like a politician who failed to deliver and one who created chaos within the political system along the way.
Melanye Price wants the Democrats to “electrify the youth” and the disadvantaged. Appeal to them with clarity and vision, she writes. That means a turn to Elizabeth Warren or Julian Castro who appeal to what the United States can be. Included especially in her argument would be a focus on young people of color who make up seven percent of the votes.
Don’t give up on whites, of course, target the Obama voters who abandoned Hillary Clinton in 2016. Don’t focus on becoming more conservative (middle of the road) but take advantage of what she sees as a resurgence of more liberal thought.
Thomas Edsall, on the other hand believes that the Democrats have to “seize the center.” Using polling data heavily, he sees just 16% of the electorate in the general election as persuadable.
Data shows that 31% of voters are very or somewhat liberal whereas 36% are very or somewhat conservative, leaving 28% moderates. The rest are unidentified. He sees the Democrats losing the identity they have traditionally had with working class and middle class voters by turning too liberal.
Democrats, therefore, should not go for candidates who provide large scale policies that promise significant change. Voters in general elections, he claims, favor small scale policies. This argues for more centrist candidates if Democrats want to succeed. Problem is the Democrat primaries are balanced towards liberal voters. Biden beware?
Charlie Warzel is the last writer. He takes a different perspective: he says the Democrats must counter Trump by focusing on use of the internet as the contemporary media of importance in elections. Targeted data should be gathered, while using memes and selfies, Twitter and Facebook as primary tools.
Why this tact? He claims that the internet is built to favor controversy and Trump excels in dominating the content of the internet. Lies and shamelessness of the content don’t matter as much as simply keeping Trump front and center. He dominates the conversation.
Democrats, Warzel advises, must embrace outrage to compete. Rather than Trump’s MAGA outrage and fear of the other, they must produce “the correct blend of righteous progressive outrage on climate, inequality and corruptions.” Whether they can compete with their integrity intact is unclear, he says.
So, which strategy is a winning one? Will it depend upon the candidate chosen? Probably.
Richard Fulton is an emeritus professor of political science.
