Skip to content

View from the Country: Israel and the Middle East

Richard Fulton

Once again, the Middle East is front and center in discussions of war and peace. Did Iran, through its client forces in the area, attack the Saudi Arabian oil base? Should America respond with force to support the Saudis?

It has been clear that the Trump foreign policy, as far as it has a coherent foreign policy, has favored autocratic regimes like that of Saudi Arabia, thus anything is possible.

What we tend to forget about when we survey the complex situations in the Middle East is the position of Israel. Arabs versus the Jewish state has produced several wars and innumerable political and economic conflicts in between those wars.

So all the flurry of activity over the attack on Saudi oil production has taken attention away from the unstable situation within the politics of Israel. They had an election in April which resulted in a razor thin win of the coalition headed by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. He is the longest serving leader of the country since its founding.

His party, the Likud, leads the coalition and is a right wing party that has guided the nation’s policies in the direction of religious nationalism. This because in a parliamentary system like Israel’s, the Prime Minister is chosen by a majority of the parliament.

If no one party gets a majority of representatives then the leading party, the Likud for many years, must find smaller parties to back it so that it can get a majority and form a government. Likud has had to look to right wing parties and ultraconservative religious parties to make its majority.

The April coalition fell apart quickly and new elections were held this last Tuesday. That means I don’t know who won (deadlines), but polls showed the Netanyahu coalition virtually tied with a party called the White and Blue (the flag’s colors) led by a former chief of the military Benny Gantz.

If the election was too close for either of the larger coalitions to win a majority in the parliament, then deals must be made if a government is to be formed.

Netanyahu has been desperate to hold onto power partly because he is being investigated for allegations of fraud and corruption. He wants a parliament that will protect him.

His campaign has been racist, claiming voting fraud by Arabs (a sixth of the electorate are Palestinian-Israeli citizens though they still have limited civil rights). He also promised to annex a third of the West Bank which is Palestinian and occupied by Israel since the 1967 war.

Netanyahu has played a patient game of placing settlers in occupied territories and then claiming Israel’s need to protect them. A two state solution has been in the works for decades, but stalled by Netanyahu with the support recently of the Trump administration.

So the election is important. Arab states will not take kindly to the annexation of portions of the West Bank into Israel. Iran is wary of the belligerent policies of Israel, supported by Trump, and is ready for war if necessary.

In case of war between Saudi Arabia and Iran, who would the U.S. support? What would Israel do? This is a volatile area and just focusing on one aspect—like the Saudi-Iran dispute—is dangerous.

An unstable Israel can’t help. What happened Tuesday probably kept their politics in a state of instability with small, often radical, parties holding the key to a majority. Though if the White and Blue party has the plurality, there are more moderate alternatives for them with which to form a government.

America is tired of continuous fighting in the area; neutrality would seem to be a better policy for the entire area, including the internal politics of Israel.

Richard Fulton is an emeritus professor of political science.

Leave a Comment