Pearls: Always beware the pot of gold

Matt Pearl
Years ago, one of my younger sister’s classmates fibbed to his fourth grade peers that he had pursued a rainbow to its end. At said rainbow’s tail, this young man boasted he had found a shiny penny on the ground.
It didn’t take much consideration for his classmates to laugh in disbelief. I mean, how does one chase the end of a rainbow anyway? And a penny? That has to be the least profitable lie in the history of kids making up stories.
Over the years, that goofy little tall tale has returned occasionally to my memory: I suppose that means the story left some sort of impression upon me. I have, since the original telling of the tale, wondered why this young man would put up such an unusually uneventful fib for peer review. Who lies about a penny at the end of a rainbow?
But if my teaching experiences have taught me anything, it is that kids typically say and do things for a reason. A lie tends to fulfill an expectation, or to gloss over some personal need or shame. Perhaps money was tight for this kid’s family; he was an intelligent young man, and thus able to comprehend that no one would believe he found a pot of gold. Maybe the story about the penny alleviated a little bit of his mental stress over finances, while maintaining material believability in the form of a simple penny.
I’m no psychologist, and I won’t play the role of one with my amateur assessments. But the return of the story to my memory on this occasion has prompted a few wonderings in my mind.
Do we, the sophisticated adults of a sophisticated society, ever fall for penny at the end of a rainbow stories? Would a politician ever be motivated to give us an unbelievable account of a policy’s success, all while disclosing a popularly conceivable reward at the end of his fictitious rainbow?
Haven’t leaders time and again paraded out a single individual, or maybe one family, from one city in the country who has benefitted from his or her programs or ideas – all to prove that what’s good for the Joneses in Lansing is good for everyone in the U.S.?
They do the same with failures, right? A program fails this couple in Phoenix, which is evidence that it won’t work for anyone anywhere.
Perhaps the next time a politician parades out Betty Such-and-Such from Tallahassee, some of us will prick up our ears and wonder, “Is this woman the penny at the end of a fake rainbow?” Maybe we should more often wonder whether we might be hearing a relatively believable testimonial at the conclusion of a mediocre) or failed) policy.
It’s tough to call folks out on these things, though. The young man with the tall tale also had a penny. None of his schoolmates were with him when he acquired the penny, so no one could indisputably refute his rainbow claim. Sometimes we all know something is a lie, but proving so ends up being a difficult, if not impossible, task.
And the opposite tactic is equally tough to navigate: it is difficult to prove that a policy is useless or corrupt by using a single example of its failure. Our perceptions differ so much that no one is a fan of every law or policy, nor is any normal person a critic of all actions by the President or Congress.
But left or right, Democrat or Republican, your leaders are famous for lifting up a shiny penny – a humble example of the value of their rainbow – and convincing you that their actions are successful. Let us be vigilant in watching for such deceptions.
On a final note, beware the pot of gold as well. Our leaders might boast of lofty treasures like unemployment and economic growth – but how often can they prove that it was their rainbow that produced success and prosperity?
Matt Pearl owns and operates newspapers in King City, Albany and Grant City.
