A View from the Country: Higher education in America

A View from the Country: Higher education in America
The scandal over wealthy parents buying their students into selective colleges and universities is disconcerting, indeed literally maddening.
Although the lengths some have been shown to go to get their children into these schools seems shocking, it should not be that surprising that the admissions system for elite schools has been skewered from the very beginning.
How do colleges and universities honestly judge applicants anyway? There are dozens of books and online sites that chronicle the secrets to getting good scores on ACT/SAT tests; hundreds of books on how to write the admissions essay; all kinds of college admissions “secrets” available (extra curricular activities in bulk, athletics, good deeds, etc.).
Still, many turn to professionals who promise elite admissions. Rick Singer was caught cheating on the system for his clients. He noted in his book that there are three ways to get in: the front door on your merits; the back door by donating in large amounts or being a legacy; or the side door, using the illicit Singers of this world.
Legacies are children of alums. For example, Donald Trump’s son-in-law Jared Kushner got into Harvard after his father, an alum, donated $25 million to the university. Legacies are five times more likely to be admitted than other students.
Yet, who benefits most from an elite education? A 2014 study found that lower income students benefit more than those students who are early poised to succeed, those with high ACT, high economic background, access to multiple extras.
Students poised to succeed tend to do well even if they don’t get into Ivy League-type schools, however. But minority students and those from families with little academic background benefit disproportionately from an elite education studies show.
Still, low income students make up just three percent of the student body of most selective schools. Even though when they graduate they make as much money lifetime as the well-to-do students.
A Gallup study found that selective school attendance did not correlate with later satisfaction in work or in having a fulfilling life, however. Can’t buy them. Ask any Northwest Missouri student to reinforce this finding.
As a matter of fact, studies have found that where you go to school, in relation to lifetime earnings, means much less than the major area of study you pursue. Engineers make much more than art majors, for example.
It is no secret that elite schools have larger endowments than less prestigious schools. That means they have the ability to finance the education of students of low-income families. But they don’t use the money for low income families proportionately.
Recruitment of students is the key; what kind of students do you pursue will determine what kind you admit. Studies have found that more selective schools tended to recruit from less diverse high schools — whiter and wealthier schools. Even the universities of Kansas and Nebraska have recruited at twice as many schools in higher income areas than in high schools in more diverse and poorer areas.
Some schools have more students from the top one percent of income families than from the bottom 60 percent of incomes. You need to recruit well to use your scholarship monies well and create diversity.
College admissions processes are complex resulting in often bizarre choices. There are many ways to scam the system. In the end, which higher education institution you go to depends on the best fit for the individual student. After all, studies have found that it is the student’s efforts and ambitions that determine success.
And success is not just in money and/or position. Remember the studies that find that even elite schools don’t necessarily bring happiness or contentment.
Richard Fulton is an emeritus professor of political science.
