Pearls: Giving clear explanations is a necessary, not basic, skill

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA
In education, we teachers are not just concerned with what our students know, but also to what depth they are able to expound upon their knowledge.
Explaining things is supposed to be one of those lower-level tasks; explaining a term or idea is supposed to fall into the fairly basic category of student understanding. But sometimes I wonder about the logic there.
From what I have observed in my years in this world, the things we struggle to explain are the very concepts that cause us distress and frustration. As a person who makes a good portion of his living relating concepts to classrooms full of students, at times it baffles me when anyone makes the claim that explaining is an elementary function.
It is not easy to do in most cases. Oh, sure, I can take half a minute and make a student understand what a poem is, or who William Cullen Bryant was, or when The Canterbury Tales were written. But explaining to a fresh mind what Transcendentalism was, or what compelled an aged Benjamin Franklin to write a self-help chapter in his autobiography – now that’s a bit more complicated.
If I could simply explain to my own kids why people get serious illnesses, or what justifications people made defending slavery two centuries ago, we could make a two-minute talk out of such matters. But that’s not how it works with young learners: they want more – to understand difficult concepts, not merely to know the bold-print textbook definition of things.
Giving clear explanations is not a basic skill. But it is certainly a necessary skill for us to acquire along the way, if for no other reason but to make ourselves better understood during times of contention or dissention.
When a person cannot adequately explain himself, he turns away from learning and logic, and turns instead toward emotionalism, fear mongering and other base responses to criticism. It baffles me to see it in the highest offices in our land: people who boast such incredible accomplishments while holding such devoted followings, but who are unable to convey their thought processes or decision-making steps to the public.
If you’re a Democrat, that’s fine. If you’re a Republican, that’s fine. If you belong to either party, but can’t explain to me why, then I’m highly unlikely to respect your opinions on politics. How can I respect an opinion that is based in a vague, unexplained set of notions?
So, when the educational experts tell me that a student’s ability to explain a concept is a lower-order skill in the scope of depth of knowledge, I say hogwash.
But my expectations regarding the ability of others to explain their actions is a two-way street. I must in turn hold myself accountable for explaining my own reasoning and decision-making. Nobody is above reproach in this nation of free speech: each of us at times can and will be called upon to account for our conceptualization of truth.
We need in particular to hold our leaders’ feet to the fire, insisting that they explain themselves, including their actions and their words. And when a public servant fires back with something like, ‘I don’t have to explain myself to you,’ then you know that you’re hearing the true confession of an empty mind. Interpret the message accurately, ‘I can’t explain myself because then you’ll see how wrong I am.’
So, I don’t teach students that explaining is easy; I teach then that explaining a difficult concept with honesty, clarity and depth is one of the hardest things that every educated person should routinely be called upon to do.
Matt Pearl owns and operates newspapers in King City, Albany and Grant City.
