Skip to content

View from the Country: Review of Amendments

View from the Country: Review of Amendments

I promised last article to continue a review of the constitutional amendments on the November ballot, so here it is.

Amendment No. 1 does several things that are aimed at reforming aspects of the state legislature; its election and its office holders.

The first thing it does is adjust the way that legislative districts are redrawn (redistricting). There is a complex system set up by the Amendment but basically redistricting lines would be drawn by a nonpartisan state demographer chosen by the leaders of the two houses of the legislature as a first step.

The demographer draws up the districts (given strict limits based upon partisan fairness and competitiveness). Each house has a reapportionment commission divided equally by party members which receives his/her work. By a 70% vote of the combined commissions, the politicians can change the demographer’s lines. Short of that, the demographer’s work stands.

The new districts must be roughly square, rectangular, or a hexagon to eliminate drawing funny lines to keep governmental units together. I told you this was complex.

Bottom line, many politicians and minority groups are against the amendment because they fear losing their jobs or influence with the new district lines. Me, I like the idea.

The amendment also limits campaign contributions from individuals or “entities” to $2500 for Senators and $2000 for House members. Both cannot accept any gifts over $5 during their term. Lastly, the amendment guarantees access to legislative records and proceedings.

Whew! That’s a lot to take in. Bottom line for me is that any reform is worth a try, especially to get rid of gerrymandering and its inequities.

Amendment 4 merely makes it easier for Bingo operations. If you like Bingo, vote yes, if you want to continue the limitations on Bingo, vote no.

The real tricky proposal on the ballot, for me at least, is Proposition D. The ballot explanation states, “Shall Missouri law be amended to fund Missouri state law enforcement by increasing the motor fuel tax…” by ten cents over four years. Note that the proposition is for law enforcement, no other beneficiary of the tax is noted in the introduction to the proposition nor, it is important to note, in the body of the proposed law.

We are told that this will benefit state and local road programs, but I can’t find this, and I looked, specified in the law itself. Even the explanation at the top of the ballot does not mention monies for state highways, only for local road construction.

So what is going on here? Maybe current state law distributes monies coming from all fuel taxes, but none of this is explained or in the proposition. The law change says specifically that all the state money is “for the actual cost of the state highway patrol.” It adds however, “Subject to appropriation.” And how does this work?

Looks to me like a bait and switch game at best. What if the legislature doesn’t want to appropriate all for the state patrol? Some for highways maybe? Just asking.

Oh, stuck at the end of the law created by Proposition D is a little noted section creating the “Emergency State Freight Bottleneck Fund.” What’s this all about? Is this the monies urban areas will get from the increased gas tax? Why is this in the proposition dealing with fuel tax increase? “Subject to appropriations”?

This thing is too “funny” looking for me to support. Spell out what you’re doing if you want my support; or maybe if you do, more people won’t support it?

The city of Maryville has the establishment of a use tax that would allow it to participate in the collection of sales taxes from online purchases and out of town purchases like automobiles. We need to have this if the state participates in the movement to tax on-line purchases. It would help make local businesses more competitive and incidentally increase local tax revenue. We shouldn’t miss out on this money.

There you have it, a complex ballot. And I haven’t even mentioned which candidates to vote for.

Richard Fulton is an emeritus professor of political science.

Leave a Comment