View from the Country: Foundation fears, a stable society

View from the Country: Foundation fears, a stable society
My last article talked about the proposition that our lives are driven, to one extent or another, by six fundamental fears. They are: the fear of poverty; the fear of criticism; the fear of ill health; of the loss of love from someone; the fear of old age; and the fear of death.
I covered poverty last week and indicated that the other fears that affect society as a whole and its politics are the fear of old age and of ill health. The fears of criticism, loss of love, and death tend to be personal fears that resonate in society but are tangential to the stability and politics of the society as a whole.
More than ever the visceral fear of ill health affects all but the highest levels of society. Most all advanced countries provide health care for everyone centered upon a single-pay insurance system. While the systems vary, data show that the jumbled system that has been jerry-rigged in America has consistently produced data that puts America below most advanced nations in most areas of effective health care— for children, effective care for women (more women die in child birth than in all other advanced countries), for the elderly, and especially for the poor.
All this within a system that costs more than twice as much as health care costs in other advanced countries. Yes, twice as much! Increasingly, the fear of ill health permeates American families because they simply cannot afford health insurance at the level that protects their ability to pay for other basic needs let alone retirement.
Pharmaceutical companies too often have monopolies on key medicines and cost many out of the use of those medicines. How many American have to choose between basic expenses (food, transportation, education) and medicines? In other developed nations the answer to this question is virtually none.
And still our system costs twice as much as theirs.
The concentration of the health industry in America is swiftly becoming indistinguishable from the European systems except that it is greatly splintered. Hospitals are becoming huge businesses that level little choice or competition in many areas while forcing doctors into their spheres.
How many cancer centers spend billions advertising for business? How much does this duplication push up patient costs? Why should they not be part of a system coordinated through a single pay system that cuts down on most of their costs?
Ah, but people don’t like those systems where they are established? Fact is they do like them, and survey after survey establishes this.
While a basic anxiety about ill health festers in American society and makes it fractious and less secure. And this problem is, of course, part of the anxiety about old age as well. How do you save for old age if all your money has to be spent on health care? How many elderly Americans (and others for that matter) don’t go to a doctor because they fear the cost?
Those who can afford the high-end health insurance packages don’t worry so much, their anxiety level is much lower. But this is increasingly a smaller percentage of Americans.
It use to be that where you worked provided a decent health insurance package but—no more. Even if there is a package, it includes higher employee input, higher deductibles, exclusions, and no, or an expensive, family plan.
The anxieties over ill-health and old age are part of the foundation of fears that are driving the divisive politics of our age. At base it is not specific policies or politicians that worry us all; it is that fundamental fear that one battle with ill health will ruin our retirement, our ability to afford the needed medication, what will happen to me when I can no longer work?
These are individual anxieties, but they echo through out our society and its politics. All three, poverty, ill-health, old age provide the present foundation of societal-wide fear. And society’s instability.
To solve our present political dilemmas we must find ways to alleviate those foundational fears.
Richard Fulton is an emeritus professor of political science.
